American Idol: Season 11 OFFICIAL thread!

[happygirl]

How horrible to think you were safe only to find out you weren't

 

[Nancy]

Awwwwww

 

[Mean Queen]

I didn't think Colton would get that upset about himself, but I knew he'd get mad about his sister. Hopefully, she comes back next year.

 

[DarthKTrava]

that last group of women looked way older than 30.

What is the age limit?

Someone was 27.

The chick with all the makeup/weird hair looked older than she is.

 

[S. C.]

How horrible to think you were safe only to find out you weren't

I'm not happy at all with the way they are doing this. Keep this kind of stuff up and their viewers will go down. Just my opinion of course.

 

[DarthKTrava]

"Welcome to the top 40". Makes me think of Casey Kasem and his countdown show.

 

[Mean Queen]

What happened to the top 40? 42 instead.

Ok, so far I think I like the guys much more this year. Phil Phillips, Colton, Adam, and the music teacher something Marcellus. Can't think of any girls I like.

 

[Nancy]

What is the age limit?

Someone was 27.

The chick with all the makeup/weird hair looked older than she is.

It's either 27 or 28.

I just don't like how they did this. Would have been better to cut them right away and not get their hopes up.

 

[Nancy]

Is that daughter of the baseball player still in the mix? I still can't put names to faces.

 

[Mean Queen]

Is that daughter of the baseball player still in the mix? I still can't put names to faces.

Yes. She's the one girl I remember that's still there since she's from my area.

 

[Nancy]

Yes. She's the one girl I remember that's still there since she's from my area.

Good to hear. I liked her voice.


See you next week.

 

[Jennasis]

Still some questionable choices tonight, and MAN was I ticked that some people were told they were through to the next round only to be cut the next morning (or a few hours later). Stupid.

 

[DianeV]

I wasnt happy with a few 2nd day cuts. The cute blonde guy that they said was so wonderful at tryouts? I thought he could make it to the end and he went home. Also the blonde single mom girl I thought should have stayed...they will regret some of the choices they made I think

 

[mandy200587]

Colton's sister, Schyler, said she believes she might come back next season to Nigel on twitter.

 

[fairestoneofall]

Still some questionable choices tonight, and MAN was I ticked that some people were told they were through to the next round only to be cut the next morning (or a few hours later). Stupid.

that whole scenario was pretty awful IMO. it's hard to tell how many they actually cut the next morning/round, but it didn't seem to be too many. they should've just made it a top 50 (or however many they had at that point).

 

[kimmar067]

....Also the blonde single mom girl I thought should have stayed...they will regret some of the choices they made I think

....I thought they were gonna keep her too....

 

[kimmar067]

Colton's sister, Schyler, said she believes she might come back next season to Nigel on twitter.

....she said it on last night's show too....

 

[kimmar067]

I think the other guy saved him, his vocals were so loud and overpowering, Cowboy kid was able to slide through. I hope he doesn't last....

...me too - he's such a jerk.

 

[kimmar067]

"Welcome to the top 40". Makes me think of Casey Kasem and his countdown show.

 

[kimmar067]