American Idol: Season 10 PART III

I think last night's result was just further evidence that this show has completely jumped the shark.

Casey before Jacob? Really?

Before Scotty, who can only sing one song well?

Before either of the girls?

Yeah...no. Since Adam Lambert lost, the show has become a bit of a joke, and it appears to be controlled completely by 12 year old girls with a very narrow palate of musical taste. They could easily fix the problems with the show by having the audience vote for who goes HOME rather than who stays, or by limiting the number of times you can vote, but they'll never do that because they like having those huge vote totals and I think they honestly welcome the occasional controversy.

It's a shame, because this used to be a very entertaining show that we could watch as a family and all enjoy. Now, it's something my 10YO DD can still get into, but I know better than to care too much about anybody with real talent, 'cause they likely won't have any shot at winning.

Nothing has changed on this show except that the judges are all sunshine and rainbows. Remember 1st year Nikki? I had no clue how she was still around week after week after week..yet she was. Every year there is someone with talent voted off before some think they should be and some that stay week after week and it makes you go :confused3. There have also been seasons where NO ONE was worth voting for at all.

I don't know why Casey got voted off before Jacob..but technically he should have been gone weeks ago since he was voted off before. Scotty? Every song he has sung has been good but he sings country. I'm 40 years over 12 years old and I throw a lot of votes for him every week. I for the life of me can't figure out why Haley is still there, Lauren I can.

I actually think this year is one of the better ones in recent history. At this time of the season I usually am pretty much down to 1 person..not this year.
 
Vote for the Worst picked... no kidding:

Jacobnocaricature.jpg


Not that it'll do any good, didn't help Paul or Casey:confused3
 

Vote for the Worst picked... no kidding:

Jacobnocaricature.jpg


Not that it'll do any good, didn't help Paul or Casey:confused3

Couldn't they at least put him in the evening dress we all know he should be wearing? He really would rock the drag queen look better than Ru Paul ever did.
 
Couldn't they at least put him in the evening dress we all know he should be wearing? He really would rock the drag queen look better than Ru Paul ever did.

Personally, I didn't like his singing from the beginning and every week I find myself asking "Who dressed him?"

Having said that, I don't know his sexual preference and I really don't care. He does seem to be someone with moral values and he's not ashamed of that.

I don't mean to preach but that comment just rubbed me the wrong way.
 
Vote for the Worst picked... no kidding:

Jacobnocaricature.jpg


Not that it'll do any good, didn't help Paul or Casey:confused3
Awww... my sweet Jacob isn't the worst! :sad1:

Couldn't they at least put him in the evening dress we all know he should be wearing? He really would rock the drag queen look better than Ru Paul ever did.
I think he could even pull it off better than Wesley Snipes did in To Wong Foo. ::yes::

jacobwendyv.jpg

How YOU doin'????
Girl, you know he's prettier than Wendy! :scared1:
And has too much class! He'd never roast his Slim Jim with a cigarette lighter!!!
:lmao:

Having said that, I don't know his sexual preference and I really don't care. He does seem to be someone with moral values and he's not ashamed of that.
Just because you have strong moral values doesn't mean you can't be gay. I have several gay friends who are very active in their church. He's never said anything about it, who knows... who cares? There are lots of straight guys out there who would make very pretty drag queens. :thumbsup2
 
For you David cook fans-

http://blog.music.aol.com/2011/04/2...?icid=main|htmlws-main-w|dl2|sec1_lnk3|211532


With a guitar, distortion pedal and a hint of swagger, season 7 'American Idol' champ David Cook helped change the paradigm of the popular Fox series. Like Chris Daughtry and Bo Bice before him, Cook introduced rock-star elements -- playing guitar onstage, using distortion pedals -- to the 'Idol' stage that delighted viewers and ultimately paved the way for people like Adam Lambert and this season's James Durbin.

Since his self-titled platinum debut and Declaration world tour, the singer is enjoying the fruits of taking a risk on 'American Idol,' but not without having a tough road to the top. Cook recently sat down with AOL Music to talk about the good times and the bad -- namely his late brother Adam, who succumbed to cancer in 2009. Since Adam's death, Cook has re-evaluated his experiences and channeled the resulting feelings into 'This Loud Morning,' the singer's sophomore album that showcases a more sensitive side while staying true to his rock roots.

You Played 'Idol' again recently; how was it returning to the stage where it all started?

Going back on the 'Idol' stage was interesting. I'll usually get a small wave of anxiety as the music starts, and about 10 to 20 seconds in, I can find my pocket and feel comfortable. I love going back. To be able to see everybody behind the scenes that you built these relationships with -- and in this case, I met the new judges and the new contestants -- it was a really fun time.

What do you think the show is missing without Simon Cowell?

I don't think they're missing anything without Simon. I think what Steven [Tyler] and J. Lo have brought to the table has really given the show a shot in the arm ... I love more than anything [that] the show seems to have recommitted itself to really allowing the audience to invest in the contestants, which is paramount to these kids coming onto the show and having success afterwards.

Do you think you were treated like that back when you were on 'Idol'?

I think we did have a different experience; But I think that every season has a different experience. I cherish the relationships I had on 'Idol.' It's all about every season building their own thing.

You recorded Simple Minds' 'Don't You (Forget About Me),' the farewell song for this season's departing 'Idol' contestants. Did you choose the song?

No, I didn't. Actually Simon Fuller ['American Idol' producer] suggested the song. Gave me a crack at it. I was a little nervous for that song actually; it's an iconic song. Every time I hear the original I always think of Judd Nelson [Bender in the John Hughes cult classic 'Breakfast Club'] on the football field with his fist in the air. So to try to kind of put my own spin on it; the last thing I wanted to do was *******ize the song. [I was] just trying to make it fun and trying to find the right vibe for it ... I'm sure the contestants that are getting sent home probably hate the damn song. But it's found its niche within the show this year, which is great to see.

Do you like '80s music?

I do! On our last tour we covered a lot of '80s songs. [Cutting Crew's] 'Died in Your Arms Tonight,' and [Johnny Hates Jazz's] 'Shattered Dreams.' I think a lot of songs that came out of the '80s had a really strong sense of melody and a really cool back beat. So they are fun to play.

What was the writing process like for 'This Loud Morning'?

The writing process on this record was long -- as it needed to be. I think as we were going on the tour for the first record we had things happen both good and bad. In an effort to really stay on the road and keep the show a priority, I really shelved all those things. Whether it be the great things like the experience of playing for 115,000 people in Manila, Philippines, or the downside like my brother passed away while we were on the road in May of '09. So as I got off the road and started writing, those things kind of resurfaced and I was forced to deal with them, and I think as a result the writing process became a little bit more therapeutic than it ever had been for me before. I think as a result this record is very much an emotionally honest record where I think there's some open-wound moments.

What's the driving inspiration behind the album?

I just wanted to make a record that really showed that a happy ending isn't always as happy as you think it might be. And I'm certainly extremely blessed to be able to do what I do with my life. I love my career and I love the people that are associated with it. But it's not always easy, and I just kind of wanted to paint a realistic viewpoint of a happy ending.

You're from Missouri; does your Midwestern heritage give you a different outlook on life than other people you meet in the music industry?

I think for me, I've always been such a homebody and I just adhere to a bit of a slower lifestyle than maybe what's considered customary in this industry. So it's always funny to me; like I remember being on the road and I'd read these articles. I would see two articles side-by-side, and one would be like "David Cook is a success story coming from 'Idol,' he sold 1.3 or 1.4 million records," and then the next article would say the same numbers but I would be perceived as the "quiet 'Idol' winner." I kind of embrace that. I love that; I love being the quiet success story.

Every time I drive to Kansas City, Mo. I see your sign on the side of Interstate 70.

Oh yeah? Have you seen it tagged yet?



No -- it's clean!

Oh good! That's good. My folks will call me every couple of months and say, ''Somebody tagged your sign and they're replacing it." I always get a laugh out of it.

Do you think the Midwest has informed your songwriting?

Yeah, I grew up on a mix of country and rock, and so I think it's impossible to say that it didn't really influence where my songwriting goes. I've always tried to adhere to finding a really strong sense of melody that you commonly find in a country theme; but I also like turning guitars up and being loud as hell.

You've shown a sensitive side since graduating from your hard-rock image on 'Idol.' What's changed for you that contributed to that?

As we move forward and hopefully put out a lot of different records, I'd like to paint different sides of myself. I guess maybe it's my attempt to fight this common urge to put things in a box and just define it completely; so I think with the first record I really tried to use songs as an avenue to paint pictures for people. With this record I definitely tried to expand the scope and have more up-tempo songs like our first single, 'Last Goodbye,' and also songs that are maybe a little bit more laid-back and more piano-driven -- songs like 'Goodbye to the Girl,' just trying different instrumentation. As we move forward I think the goal is to show as much musicianship as possible and to really show the limits of my musicianship.

What's your best advice for the current crop of 'Idol' hopefuls?

You know, I actually talked to them about it last night. Sleep as much as you possibly can. You know, three years into this I'm still fighting for a nap half the time. So I think past that, who knows how long? The length of the ride for these people is individualized to each person, so I think you make sure that you're processing and embracing everything around you because who knows how long it'll last?

How do you unwind after a big show or day or promo and interviews?

A good meal and as much sleep as possible is usually a pretty good remedy for me.

Do you have any surprising hobbies that might have been your life had you not gone on 'Idol' or gotten a record deal?

I studied graphic design in college and I still love doing that as much as I can, probably much to [my label's] chagrin. I tried to be very involved in the visual aspects of this record, so I was heavily involved in the cover concept and design on this album. So I'd probably be doing that if the 'Idol' thing didn't pan out.

You played baseball as well. I heard you once pitched to [the St. Louis Cardinals'] Albert Pujols.

Yeah, I did. I hung a curve-ball that he obliterated. It's funny, you know, fast forward and we're playing before the home-run derby at the all-star game in St. Louis couple years ago, and I got within 20 ft. from him, and because he was a home-town guy, the press was just swarming him, and I was just like, "I'll just leave him alone." But I'm sure he's hit enough home runs since then that he's probably forgotten all about that hung curve-ball.
 
Do we know if DC is dating anyone? just trying to figure out if someone is a nutter...:eek:
 
Do we know if DC is dating anyone? just trying to figure out if someone is a nutter...:eek:

I know that he had been dating Kimberly Caldwell and then after her he dated Lacey Schwimmer, but I don't think that he's dating anyone right now....
 
Last night, Jimmy said something about how she didn't know who she was and they bleeped whatever she said, Ryan reminded her to watch her language, and then she was all attidudinal about how she DOES know who she is, blah, blah, blah. Just shut up and take the criticism. I think it's something I've seen in her all along, an arrogance, that made me not like her. I just hope the rest of America sees it now, too. And it's not just "diva" like Jacob, either, but a true, deep-set arrogance.


Okay, I think you are def. onto something here!!!

But, before I will continue... I will have to say that the complete ULTIMATE in arrogance... "I am god".... right up there with those like Celine Dion... Was PIA..... And, no matter how much mad vocal talent she has... I hated her from week 2 or 3 for that reason... Everybody was like, how could Pia get voted off???? No surprise to me!

Anyhow, I have seen a LOT of potential in Haley... Out of all the top contenders this season, up until now, she is the one who has gone above and beyond to perform like heck on that stage... When she has done the group numbers, singing with the other girls (only two left now...) that is when this has been very, very, obvious.

But, yes, something has really been holding her back... It is like her neon lips are a big sign of just how greatly she thinks she shines...
And, this is not the first time that Haley has been told that she needs to do more to find out just who she is and define herself as an artist...
There are times where I have seen a young Mariah in her...

I have always said that she lacked 'maturity'...
And that is obvious as well.

Instead of being 'professional' and mature on stage... It is often like she is a high school kid, just having too much fun with herself when she is up there.

Just like Pia... I think Haley has incredible potential...
But, it looks very unlikely that they will be able to overcome the things that are in their way.
 
Instead of being 'professional' and mature on stage... It is often like she is a high school kid, just having too much fun with herself when she is up there.

Might as well call Steven Tyler an un-professional performer then. He has the time of his life and a lot of fun when he's on stage and performing with Aerosmith. He's never takes himself seriously onstage and he still puts out great performances.
 
:lmao: You are SOOO bad.

I don't get the entire season. No one to really care for, no one to add to my sig... NOTHING. :confused3

Scotty and Lauren are talented but not my type of singing. AND they both trigger my gag reflex when they speak. :scared:

Gacob... oh PLEASE. Every year American Idol digs from the bottom of the barrel of the AA singers and almost certainly pick one that CANNOT WIN. Heck even THE VOICE had two GREAT contenders... why the HECK can't we find one decent representative? :confused3

James: I liked his last song but that was IT. He is a good performer but he just sort of turns me off as a person. :sad2:

Hailey: I actually like her genre but have never been really thrilled with what she puts out. She is just okay, nothing special, nothing great, just okay. I don't HATE her like the others do, at least she has a MODICUM of soul, something Casey tries to portray. :sad2:

Casey: Ugh. In my humble opinion he TRIED to be cool and jazzy but fell amazingly short. I didn't find him funny or appealing, more goofy and creepy. :dancer:

In years past, I don't think I've agreed with you this much, Robin, but I pretty much agree with everything you've said. While I don't mind Scotty and Lauren as much as you, they're no Carrie Underwood to me. Haley's my favorite at this point and I can't see anyone taking her place in the next month. Granted, she has no shot of winning and honestly she probably shouldn't win (because I do agree with Iovine that she hasn't quite solidified who she is as a performer week in and week out)...granted she has a nonchalant attitude towards the whole affair (which usually turns me off, but seems rather endearing on her)...granted her growls are sometimes more irritating than not...but I'm still rooting for her.

Of course, I won't pick up a phone to vote, though...
 
I don't see Haley as arrogant. Gee, at this level most are quite "confident" Lauren seems to have the greatest problem with (the lack of) "self esteem" :confused3
 
Casey before Jacob, Haley, Lauren, and the one-trick country pony ? What a joke. Casey has more talent in his pinky than those 4 combined. Let's face it - tween teeny-boppers would not know talent if it hit them in the face. I recommended The Voice - much better show.
 





Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom