Am I overreacting?

Is there a crosswalk with a light at the street? If so then I think he should be fine as long as he has been taught the safety rules. If not then I think your view would make more sense.
 
I honestly could not let my child that young cross a railroad track. In my old town, we had some teens get hit and killed by a train for doing something foolish. They crossed a train bridge and when they realized they were in danger, they had no way out. All three dead.

I just would be concerned that an unsupervised child just would not be careful enough. I realize there isn't a bridge--but it is precarious enough to be of concern to me.


At that age, I was walking alongside an unshouldered highway with dangerous curves to walk the half mile or so to a friends house. To this day I have no idea what my mother was thinking and I shudder that she allowed that. Knowing now what I didn't know then--I really don't think she thought it out properly on how dangerous that was.

I would be concerned.
 
I think you handled it well, but I would lean to letting an almost 10 year old cross the street as described.
 
I think you are overreacting. It is a town of 500 people. Your son already showed you that he can safely cross the street to get there and back. Besides, he is 9 1/2, he is not a baby. At that age he should be able to cross a street, even a semi-busy street, safely.
 

You know your child best- and I think this depends more on the child than the age. At 10 I would definitely have let my daughter do this... but not my son- he was very impulsive, if he saw something in the road he'd stop and pick it up, things like that.
 
DS9 (will be 10 in Sept) rides the bus to my grandma's after school, and stays there for a couple of hours until DH or I get off work. Grandma lives in a very small town, maybe 500 people. We live out in the country, on a pretty busy road, so he has been having a ball going to neighbors houses (there are several kids his age in a one block radius of Grandma's house), and riding bikes and scooters up and down the street and around the block. Grandma is 85, though still gets around well, and my uncle and cousin, both bums, are there, so there's not a lot of supervision, but there's always someone around.

In this little town, there is one business, a convenience-type store, they sell hamburgers and gas, and miscellaneous stuff. It is about 50 yards or so from Grandma's. You cross a railroad track, and a fairly busy 2 lane road, to get to it.

He and I were sitting on the porch last week, and I asked him if anything exciting had happened that day. He said one thing, that he got to go to the store by himself. My cousin wanted a coke, so he gave DS money to buy them each one. I asked if he had looked both ways, he said he had, and that it was fun going alone. I told him that's great, it sounds like he did a good job, but I would really rather he not cross that street by himself until he's a little older. He said okay, and that was that.

I have this horrible fear of him getting hit by a car, so I'm not sure if I'm just feeding into my phobia, or if I'm being reasonable. Opinions? :confused3


How busy can the street be with only 500 residents? IMHO you are overreacting. By that age I was crossing busy streets in towns with tens of thousands of residents and it was the main street in town. One learns valuable lessons by doing. An almost 10 year old is old enough to know how to properly cross a street. I was a school crossing guard at the age of 11. All the guards were 11 when they started. We made sure the little kids crossing a very busy street were safe.
 
I think you handled it well, but I would lean to letting an almost 10 year old cross the street as described.

I agree. Maybe I'm way off base because I have no knowledge of the area but how busy can a street in a town of 500 people be?
 
There is a lot of factors here, but what it really boils down to is you're the parent and it's your decision.

I lived 50 ft from a railroad track all my life while growing up, so that wouldn't be much of a consideration. The busy road would, but it would depend on how busy and the child.

We live close to an intersection of 2 busy roads. One must be crossed to get to the gas station down the road. I could see my son going there ay almost 10, but come and talk to my in 5 years and see if my decision is the same.
 
You know your child best- and I think this depends more on the child than the age. At 10 I would definitely have let my daughter do this... but not my son- he was very impulsive, if he saw something in the road he'd stop and pick it up, things like that.

I was going to post the same exact thing. I would have let my dd at age 10 do that, but my ds who is now 10, no way.

When I was 10, my uncle used to send me to the store by myself to buy him cigarettes :laughing:
 
I was going to post the same exact thing. I would have let my dd at age 10 do that, but my ds who is now 10, no way.

When I was 10, my uncle used to send me to the store by myself to buy him cigarettes :laughing:

I remember walking to the store to get my mom cigarettes, with a note saying it was ok for me to buy them for her and a blank check she signed and I filled out when I got to the store. :lmao: I was 9. At the same age I used to walk to the grocery store, do all the grocery shopping, called her from the store before I was ready to check out, she would drive down and pick me up. I LOVED grocery shopping...then :lmao:. We lived in a town of about 10,000 people, the grocery store was downtown, about 6 blocks from our house.
 
I agree. Maybe I'm way off base because I have no knowledge of the area but how busy can a street in a town of 500 people be?

My Mom's family live in a very small town- there are less than 100 kids in their K-8 school... BUT they live on a VERY busy road... it's a "through" road if that makes any sense.
 
I remember walking to the store to get my mom cigarettes, with a note saying it was ok for me to buy them for her and a blank check she signed and I filled out when I got to the store. :lmao: I was 9. At the same age I used to walk to the grocery store, do all the grocery shopping, called her from the store before I was ready to check out, she would drive down and pick me up. I LOVED grocery shopping...then :lmao:. We lived in a town of about 10,000 people, the grocery store was downtown, about 6 blocks from our house.

Its amazing how much things have changed!
 
Its amazing how much things have changed!

Not really, kids in our old town still do the same. Peoples PERCEPTION has changed. In reality things are no more or less dangerous now, what has changed is the instant access to news so it SEEMS like it is more dangerous. Also, kids then were given the freedom to roam and because they were, they developed "street smarts". There were "creepy" guys in our old town, we just knew to stay away from them. We talked about not talking to strangers, not taking candy from strangers, etc. when we were in school but because we walked 8 blocks to school, crossing busy streets, alone, we learned to trust our instincts where today, kids don't get that opportunity.
 
Not really, kids in our old town still do the same. Peoples PERCEPTION has changed. In reality things are no more or less dangerous now, what has changed is the instant access to news so it SEEMS like it is more dangerous. Also, kids then were given the freedom to roam and because they were, they developed "street smarts". There were "creepy" guys in our old town, we just knew to stay away from them. We talked about not talking to strangers, not taking candy from strangers, etc. when we were in school but because we walked 8 blocks to school, crossing busy streets, alone, we learned to trust our instincts where today, kids don't get that opportunity.

Kids in your old town still walk up to the corner store with a blank check and a permission note to buy cigarettes? I think that's what the PP was referring to... ;)
 
Kids in your old town still walk up to the corner store with a blank check and a permission note to buy cigarettes? I think that's what the PP was referring to... ;)

Ok, not to buy cigarettes but a blank check to buy stuff, yes. Around here most stores don't even check ID when you write a check.
 
My Mom's family live in a very small town- there are less than 100 kids in their K-8 school... BUT they live on a VERY busy road... it's a "through" road if that makes any sense.

That's what this road is, it connects the 2 large towns on either side of Grandma's small one, and is the main road for all the people living in that area, so it does get busy.
 
I was going to post the same exact thing. I would have let my dd at age 10 do that, but my ds who is now 10, no way.

When I was 10, my uncle used to send me to the store by myself to buy him cigarettes :laughing:

We would buy candy, then tell my uncle there wasn't enough money left for the cigarettes. :rotfl: They also had the old-fashioned coke machines there, with the cokes in bottles and the metal caps. When we were pretty young, 7 or 8 maybe, my cousins and I roamed all over town picking up coke bottles off the side of the road, and taking them to the store to get the nickel deposit. That's why I feel bad about not letting DS go alone, we had some great times.

The town has grown since then, though, and the traffic is a lot worse than before.

I think I'll stand by my rule until school starts again, and we'll revisit it then. Thank you, everyone, for the perspective! :goodvibes
 
It is across the street in a town of 500. P

Just because it's in a town of only 500, and only across the street, doesn't mean it can't be a heavily travelled road. It could very possibly be a major highway.
 
I think it's ok for you to ask him not to cross the street and tracks alone. Better tell the grownups around there that you don't want him to or they will be asking him and putting him in a weird position. Then you'll have to argue with all the 'their house, their rules' people here on the board, lol! j/k about the Dis folks but seriously, let your cousin, uncle and Grandma know.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom