Our stay was great!! We were in garden view but we watched the fireworks from the beach EVERY night. To be COMPLETELY honest we were there for 7 days. Our room was cleaned exceptionally well for the first 4. The last 3 I could tell that we had a different mousekeeper

...It wasn't horrible but we could definitely tell the difference. I think like anything else it comes down to a person's work ethic. Our first mousekeeper was VERY detail oriented you could tell that she did the mirrors--the patio doors --(we have 3 kids so fingerprints are our friends

) we got extra shampoo/soap/ and fresh towels even when we hung them over the shower curtain rod (in case you don't know this means that you do not need new towels--it's disney's way of being eco friendly) The one at the tail end of our vacation vacuumed and straightened the beds but that was about it

We did not have any issues with broken fixtures or mold. The room did not seem dark to us but then again our furniture at home is mostly chocolate colored so our opinion may be biased

Captain cooks was good...pretty clean although at PEAK times the area where the drinks and ketchup are kept could get a little icky...but again this was PEAK lunch and dinner times..Any other time it was clean and well kept. We really had a wonderful time. I have to admit to having some doubts too after reading some of the recent reports but we had such a great experience we are going back