Hi- I am probably going to get slammed for this, but here it goes. . . We returned from a trip last week. We drove down and made it one day rather than the two we had planned. So, I called CRO from the car and booked one night at All Star Movies (we were in the Mighty Ducks 2 bldg). We stayed the rest of our trip at BWV in a 1-bedroom. Given that it was a value resort, I certainly didn't expect anything like what we had at BWV, but I must say I was disappointed. My biggest complaint is that the room was so small. It was just me, DH, and DD, but I felt like we were on top of each other. I sincerely felt like I was at a movie-themed Motel 6. Before I called CRO, I called the Hilton at WDW (we'd stayed there before and liked it). It was $20 cheaper than the All-Stars, but I went with the All-Stars hoping for the "disney magic." In retrospect, I wish I had saved $20, gotten a nicer room, and stayed at the Hilton.
So, all that said, I wouldn't rule out ASMo, I'd just really explore all the options first before making the decision.