The old "tickets" are used up. The system isn't going to try to use them. It will use the live tickets.
Since your other thread said, I think, that you're going to try to have two sets of tickets on each person's profile, you will *have to* go to guest services BEFORE entering a park and have THEM prioritize them.
But they might not even be tickets you're seeing. I have all sorts of random cards on my account, and we haven't had anywhere near that many APs (I think only two years did we have them).
The *cards* on my account, I deactivated. I don't have them, never did, and don't know what they are.