Don't get me wrong, we've done
DDP and Alfredo's on our last two trips (this most recent trip, it was free!), but the marriage appears strained.
.
On our recent Labor Day Weekend visit, an Evening EMH many of whom had free DDP CS credits, strained the somewhat ambitious service of Alfredo's mightily. This place might be better off trying to be a "Signature" restaurant but then, I believe, most diners would seek out a Tony's equivalent instead.
Fwiw, there were a lot of NorthEasters' there during this time and most of us love our Italian food. Still there was a big "gap" between what Alfredo's was trying to be and what they actually delivered given the big crowds that wanted moderately-priced (free DDP!) Italian chow.
At the same time, a DDP user can feel nickel & dimed at Alfredo's by the extra charges and other revenue enhancers. For example, I was "encouraged" to order a dessert when I really didn't want one because the restaurant and servers are compensated by Disney when they put one on the bill. We didn't use our "free drink" but were charged separately, extra for the liter-size of sparkling water. I guess that's fair, but I didn't feel it was so magical when the waitress asked if I wanted my change back after paying $8 (including tax & automatic 18% gratuity) for our San Pellogrino. You bet I got my change back!
My wife loves the Fettucine, but I believe it might be a better dining value and service experience in New York at Rockefeller Center.