I know I should've jumped on those prices but I decided to wait for a definite answer from my SIL & MIL to commit to going with us on the Thanksgiving cruise on the Magic and to wait for the few extra miles to post to my account for another free ticket on Airtran. Well, lo and behold if they didn't snatch those $99 one-way fares away just one day too early for me to book for the other 3 people in my party.

$99 to $256 overnight!

Just my luck.

I always seem to be a day late and a dollar short. I'm hoping they'll adjust fares in the next few months, downward that is, so I can buy the remaining 3 tickets I need.

If not, I'm going to have to suck it up and pay the $256. I should've just told SIL to shut up and enjoy the free cruise at those prices.
We like direct service on Delta's smaller regional jets. We're flying back home from our cruise with them. The Delta jets have more leg room than Airtran does for DH. At 6'5" he prefers the space the regional jets provide him. It's not a big difference, but still a noticeable difference. He has more walking "head" clearance on Airtran but he's only standing for a few moments. Our family in general likes the friendly attendants on Airtran. We've had some nice ones on Delta, but the ones on Airtran have been consistently good.
I'll always choose flight times and price over who I'm flying with when it comes to these two airlines. Delta had the flight time on the way home and Airtran had the price on the way there...or at least they did for a few days.