Okay Buffalo just isn't an option -- it is costing us $1400 and change for four of us to fly this January out of Ottawa.
That's actually not too bad for a Canadian origination flight.
We always fly out of Syracuse, too. It is about 3.25 hours from the east end of Ottawa so we always go down the night before and stay at the Best Western Airport Inn. The park and fly rate is about $130 or so. Depending on what time our return flight comes in, sometimes we stay the night before heading back as well. When you factor in 1 or 2 nights in hotel in Syracuse, breakfast and a tank of gas, that's going to get you pretty close to an extra $300-$350. If you get the $99 flights, for four people that's going to run you about $950. Add $350 to that and you are pretty close to the $1400. you paid from Ottawa. For a savings of a hundred bucks, I probably wouldn't go to the trouble of driving to Syracuse (unless the flight times were significantly better, direct flights, etc). You did pretty good!