Go with AKL. We've not stayed there, but we have visited for dinner a few times. It's wonderful.
If you want to save some money, here's what we did - we shipped a box of breakfast stuff and snacks ahead of our arrival - bagels, jelly, peanut butter, plastic forks and knives, the new cereal that comes in a bowl already, etc. In AKL, you'll have fridge in your room - buy some milk and keep it in the fridge.
Also, having done the dining plan when it included appetizer, entree and dessert, and now doing the basic plan with no appetizer, I'd say you'll be fine. I can't remember if the deluxe is all TS or not, but there are good counter service places to eat.