We stay at both. When in WDW we stay at the GF RPC and when at USO we always stay at the PBH CL. I personally perfer the PBH overall . In our dozens of stays at the PBH I haved never ever seen "hundreds" of peoiple in the club room. I have also never seen them run out of food. The evening offerings are different from the GF. The GF in the past year has been offering theme nights of food one night Mexican, Asian, Italian. At the PBH it is Antipasti, as well as wine and beer...it is an Italian Riviera themed hotel. Neither of the hotel club level offerings are meant to be a meal, with the exception of breakfast. At the PBH there is always cans of soda, bottles of water and coffee and tea and cookies. After breakfast there is a smoothie selection. Evenings are desserts, cookies and liquors. We have stayed equally in both hotels and have never been disappointed in the PBH. The rooms are larger, the service better and the hotel is just beautiful. You will not be disappointed.