If you would prefer a sit down meal rather than CS (I would), then I would suggest eating in MK for the convenience factor.
We have enjoyed CP and Tony's. We didn't really like the food at LTT. The Castle is just too expensive now and not worth the inflated price.
I wouldn't make an ADR any later than 5:30p - 5:45p myself. That way you'll be done by around 6:30p -6:45p.