A Plea/Request

[LarryJ]

I try and visit the DIS camping forum mainly to see if I can help out someone with a real question and will admit I'm not a chatter, but do enjoy threads like the pictures of the day, but when I just looked at that thread it had turned into the "Useless facts trype" chit-chat thread that I almost never look at and that's just me no offense to those that enjoy that sort of stuff. I just had to scroll thru two pages of chit-chat with no pictures. My plea is can we please keep the chit-chat in one thread and not let it take over the more informative threads.

Flame suit on since I'm sure some with take issue with what I've said, but I've never been one to hold my tongue when I don't think something is right.

Larry

 

[VACAMPER]

No need for a flame suit. sometimes a picture/comment is made and it just goes south from there. We tend to forget what thread we're on. No harm was intended.

 

[TheFlame]

Larry, I totally agree with you and I am "TheFlame!"
I have argued this point on many threads and all it has gotten me is put on the ignore list of those that can't take others opinions. If you are one of the "guys" maybe your request will be heard. I too am really tired of reading about stuff that has nothing to do with the topic or Disney for pages trying to catch up on a good question. Some posters are harmless and don't mean to start something, but others just do it on purpose or don't care. But, then again, I probably am wasting my time even typing this!

 

[clkelley]

Yep, I agree. A little joking is fun, but especially things like picture of the day and picture of your site, and FAQ threads should really stay on topic.

 

[Disney Campers]

Larry I agree, when I look at the Picture of the day i only want to see pictures, no chit chat or signatures. I will try and separate out the comments and chatter into another thread. Some of the pictures have lost there hosting and those i will delete.

The main purpose of the forum is for trip planning so we need to keep the off topic posts to a minimum and use the chit chat thread for that purpose.

 

[stacktester]

I was thinking the same thing as well Larry. I guess I got used to TCD and Ynottony posting so many good pics.

 

[BLUEEYEDGIRL]

i'm new to the disboards, and already have been aggravated by some threads going way off topic. i'm still learning how to navigate and sometimes never even figure out the original question or topic. thanks for addressing this!

 

[LarryJ]

Larry I agree, when I look at the Picture of the day i only want to see pictures, no chit chat or signatures. I will try and separate out the comments and chatter into another thread. Some of the pictures have lost there hosting and those i will delete.

The main purpose of the forum is for trip planning so we need to keep the off topic posts to a minimum and use the chit chat thread for that purpose.

WOW that was a lot of work splitting that thread up since I have been a moderator on another major site and know how time consuming and difficult it can be keeping us rowdies under control at times. On that other site I couldn't move a post w/o taking all the "linked" replies with it.

Now since I'm poor at following directions ... at least according to DW ... I need to remember to disable my signature when I post in the base thread

THANK YOU,

Larry

 

[John VN]

I'll agree with the others regarding detours in threads.

What also seems to happen more frequently compared to the past is the drifting of a thread towards the party/drinks topic.

 

[stacktester]

I'll agree with the others regarding detours in threads.

What also seems to happen more frequently compared to the past is the drifting of a thread towards the party/drinks topic.

And your point is??????? The fort, beer, kungaloosh and wreckless golf cart driving. What other topic is there?

 

[CaptKen]

Aw come on!!! How many times can a picture of a campsite be posted, bus routes explained, how much a golf cart costs or which loops are dog loops. We have to take them off topic just to keep folks coming back or this place would get real boring real quick. I can't think of any topic concerning FW that hasn't been discussed several dozen times. It is the nature of the beast. Now where is Rog when he's needed?

 

[BigDaddyRog]

Apparently....all thats required to keep a lively board(meaning one that has multiple daily posts, answers to all questions about Disney AND camping in general,within minutes...not days, like most forums)is straight facts and strict rules. If this is the way the "new" camping board is going to be, it doesnt sound like much fun. Its kinda funny....as irritating and aggravating as all the "mindless dribble" is....it sure seems to have brought in lots of new regulars in the past few months who really seem to enjoy the boards here. They come in and ask the usual questions about "best loops" or "should I get the dining plan or not" or "where are the pet loops located"...but tend to stay around because its a great sorurce of daily information and fun....which is what I thought camping was supposed to be. Id be willing to bet there are at least 40 -50 people who post here regularly, simply because the company kept here is warm and welcoming. If its just going to be the cold hard facts from now on......I have a gut feeling that the regulars(the ones who ANSWER all the questions for the newcomers)will find a board that doesnt mind some entertainment mixed in with its information. I personally LOVE the regualrs here and the way we all get along....the answers to every question is handeled withing the first page or two of very thread....how many different answers are really needed for the question "How clean are the comfort stations?"...There's a wonderful vibe on this board, its VERY alive....and I personally LOVE IT LIKE THAT, and would not have a reason to continue frequenting this little camping paradise of knowledge and friendliness if it were to change. JMHOOBY!!!! (Thanks 2goofs!!!)
Am I alone in this opinion? Are there others who agree that the direction the conversations usually take are what makes this board what it is?

 

[AlyLynn]

Well said! I know this is the ONLY board I have ever posted on.
The people are so friendly and helpful.

 

[abbdrey]

Apparently....all thats required to keep a lively board(meaning one that has multiple daily posts, answers to all questions about Disney AND camping in general,within minutes...not days, like most forums)is straight facts and strict rules. If this is the way the "new" camping board is going to be, it doesnt sound like much fun. Its kinda funny....as irritating and aggravating as all the "mindless dribble" is....it sure seems to have brought in lots of new regulars in the past few months who really seem to enjoy the boards here. They come in and ask the usual questions about "best loops" or "should I get the dining plan or not" or "where are the pet loops located"...but tend to stay around because its a great sorurce of daily information and fun....which is what I thought camping was supposed to be. Id be willing to bet there are at least 40 -50 people who post here regularly, simply because the company kept here is warm and welcoming. If its just going to be the cold hard facts from now on......I have a gut feeling that the regulars(the ones who ANSWER all the questions for the newcomers)will find a board that doesnt mind some entertainment mixed in with its information. I personally LOVE the regualrs here and the way we all get along....the answers to every question is handeled withing the first page or two of very thread....how many different answers are really needed for the question "How clean are the comfort stations?"...There's a wonderful vibe on this board, its VERY alive....and I personally LOVE IT LIKE THAT, and would not have a reason to continue frequenting this little camping paradise of knowledge and friendliness if it were to change. JMHOOBY!!!! (Thanks 2goofs!!!)
Am I alone in this opinion? Are there others who agree that the direction the conversations usually take are what makes this board what it is?

Hi BDR - I agree with you. I think all the regulars on the board are very informative and always answer any questions with a great deal of thought drawing from their personal experiences. I initially found the boards while searching for information on the type of people that visit Ft. Wilderness and their camping needs, but I have stayed around because I love to read what everyone has to say. I find that while some of the opinions are differing, everyone seems to get along and have fun. I do not always answer threads, but I sign in almost daily now to see who is on and what the current topics are.

I think this board is very fun and I would not change it at all. I guess if people are having a discussion that you are not interested in, then maybe just skip that thread.

 

[des1954]

Rog-

I couldn't agree more!! (And as ususal, very well put!) Yeah, threads sometimes tend to go a little "south" on us, but that's part of the fun!!! If folks wanted "just the facts, ma'am", they would look at the FAQ thread, find their answer, and never post a question.

 

[PanFanAL]

I'm still pretty new here but I thought I'd chime in. I think both are correct. The photo thread should not contain all of the chatting. But I don't have a problem with the others as long as questions are answered. I usually enjoy the responses. You guys are all as crazy as I am.

 

[BigDaddyRog]

I'm still pretty new here but I thought I'd chime in. I think both are correct. The photo thread should not contain all of the chatting. But I don't have a problem with the others as long as questions are answered. I usually enjoy the responses. You guys are all as crazy as I am.

You're right...I didnt mean to insinuate that their aren't several threads that should be considered OFF LIMITS, such as ANY STICKY thread, and PICTURE OF THE DAY AT THE FORT thread(...edit...I dont see any harm in a small amt of comments for the benefit of the photos...but 3 pages WAS a bit much)

Disney Campers(moderator), I think it was very nice of you to go through the trouble of seperating all the comments from the picture of the day thread instead of just deleting them.

And Larry J, I hope you dont consider my above comment as a flame directed at you....it was not a flame at all. I just feel it is VERY IMPORTANT to the livelihood of this forum that we are allowed to be what campers are....social and SUPERIOR to non-campers!!!

 

[bigdisneydaddy]

The sepearation of the picture thread is a good thing, it must have taken a very long time to complete that, Thanks Scott.

This board like several other that I participate in, has a tendency to veer off course. I, myself have been guilty of causing it many times, its sometimes the nature of a social interaction for that to happen. LarryJ makes a very good and very timely point and I think the board will be better for it. Having been around here for a while, its easy to forget that there are new people who actually come here to learn.

Anyways, thanks for the refocus.

 

[proudmomof4]

I try and visit the DIS camping forum mainly to see if I can help out someone with a real question and will admit I'm not a chatter, but do enjoy threads like the pictures of the day, but when I just looked at that thread it had turned into the "Useless facts trype" chit-chat thread that I almost never look at and that's just me no offense to those that enjoy that sort of stuff. I just had to scroll thru two pages of chit-chat with no pictures. My plea is can we please keep the chit-chat in one thread and not let it take over the more informative threads.

Flame suit on since I'm sure some with take issue with what I've said, but I've never been one to hold my tongue when I don't think something is right.

Larry

Thank you so much for bringing this up, I do agree, when I looked at the pic of the day thread yesterday there were 2 pages of just chit chat. I go there to see the pictures, but I didn't see the harm in a response directly to the picture, but what happened was too much.

Larry I agree, when I look at the Picture of the day i only want to see pictures, no chit chat or signatures. I will try and separate out the comments and chatter into another thread. Some of the pictures have lost there hosting and those i will delete.

Thanks, but there are still lots of posts where I can not see the pictures, is that just my computer?

I'll agree with the others regarding detours in threads.

What also seems to happen more frequently compared to the past is the drifting of a thread towards the party/drinks topic.

I also agree with this, I know there is no harm in joking around, but it does get old after a while when so many threads end up turning to beer and kungalush

I'm still pretty new here but I thought I'd chime in. I think both are correct. The photo thread should not contain all of the chatting. But I don't have a problem with the others as long as questions are answered. I usually enjoy the responses. You guys are all as crazy as I am.

But then I also agree with this too, I really enjoy reading all of the funny responses, except when it turns to the beer and kungalush, but then I just quickly scroll past all of those until I spot one that is about something else.

So I agree with both points of view in this, I think people just need to use some common sense and not let things get so out of hand or move it to the chit-chat thread

 

[bigdisneydaddy]

Careful with the beer discussion Proudmom, from where I sit, you are an enabler

Rog... this isnt the only dysfuntional family that many of us belong to.