SCARY Costumes, con't.

Thanks, everybody, for your suggestions and support!!
What does Tricia think of adding black tights under one of the short skirts? (And what do you think about it for that matter?) That would give them more freedom to move around and not expose them to the whole world... You could even fray them a little below the knees to fit in with the whole pirate theme.
Yikes!! I'm glad I only have boys! Sorry I don't have any suggestions for you... I do like that McCalls pattern though. Has Tricia seen that one yet?
Wow...just wanted to say I'm glad I have boys!
With a little work, I like either of the ones Tricia picked. But again...that's only IF she sticks to the agreement!
I like the second one best....with Mom Adjustments.
The McCall's patterns are great!
You've got your work cut out for you...I'm SO glad I have a boy!!
Okay... we've made a bit of progress!
First, I had a very kind PM offer from
Dreamer&Wisher (Nancy). Hopefully, we will be meeting them some time during the
MNSSHP! She is an experienced seamstress and has made some darling outfits for her DD, Abby. Her PTR link is below:
http://www.disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2152965.
Nancy offered to alter any costume Tricia chose or even to make one from a sewing pattern!!

I was so disappointed in what was offered commercially that I jumped at the chance and accepted!! How wonderful, I thought! I'll just order a custom costume from Nancy and that would be perfect!!
I showed Tricia the McCalls pattern, plus a few others I found online. Her response was tepid at best. (Although the thought of being able to have a say in the design process did appeal to her.) Problem is, she really likes the two commercial choices she had selected.
Ed and I reviewed the two choices and decided that Choice #1 was just a bit too tight and suggestive. Choice # 2 seemed more do-able... especially if she accepted "alterations" as needed and wore tights or leggings underneath...
Choice # 2:
http://www.halloweenexpress.com/sout...e-p-11808.html
So my plan is this:
I'll order the costume and have Tricia try it on. She may change her mind once she sees it in person and there's plenty of time to return it. If it needs some sewing alteration, I will ask Nancy for help.
If she decides that the costume does not live up to expectations, then we will pick a sewing pattern and I will take her measurements and order an appropriate costume from Nancy.
Ed, Tricia, and I have agreed that this seems to be a fair resolution... I will be keeping you posted on the outcome, naturally!!
On a related note, while looking for pirate costumes for Tricia, we found one that we thought would be
perfect for Ed!
http://www.costumes4less.com/Captain-Black-Costume_AC14186_Prod.aspx
There's no silk shirt, plumed feathers, or striped pants!!

We joked that it really isn't much of a stretch from his SRU (SWAT) uniform!!!

All he had to do now is decide whether he wants to carry a sword or a pistol!!
Billy has his pirate costume from last year...
(See the "hook?")
Now I've got to start thinking about MINE!!
Kathy