tartemis - I'm really sorry to hear you had such a bad experience on your first BC stay.

Tough to pay so much and plan for so long only to be disappointed. I'm surprised at the word "dingy" as that is the last word I would apply to the BC!!

So light and airy. I wonder if you were there before the recent refurb?
Our first BC stay was right after a wonderful stay at AKL, and we didn't love it. BC was nice, but didn't have the intense theming of AKL and we were there in December when there was a cold snap and weren't able to use the pool. We liked it, but did not feel the magic. Tried YC a couple years later and enjoyed it immensely, loved the rooms and the feel of the resort and the CMs were so charming. We agreed if we wanted to stay in the Epcot area, YC would be our go to resort.
A few years went by, and a friend reported on her first trip to the BC (she's a big AKL & GF fan, too) and she was in love! Her review was so glowing, and her photos of the new room decor looked so inviting we wanted to give the resort another shot and booked a few days before our GF stay. LOVED the resort! The new room decor is restful, the CMs were very sweet to us and we loved SAB and the short walk to Epcot.
It seems many GF lovers do tend to prefer YC over BC - not sure why, as Yacht is all dark woods and leather, rich tones. Still, it is a quieter resort than BC and that serenity may appeal to those who are used to the GF. As I said earlier, the Boardwalk is a good choice if you prefer the lighter colors, it's a beautiful resort and I think the rooms are prettier than YC's current room decor. It is a convention resort as well, so the vibe at the Inn may feel more like the GF. The proximity to so many restaurants in the Epcot area is a huge plus!
Good luck! I hope you are able to make a choice that you feel good about.
