I had: the bruschetta, spicy italian sausage, & crema limone.
My wife had: The mozzarella and tomatoes, pork chop (not on the menu), and a chocolate torte/cake.
FQ: 8/10
This may very well be due to preference. We didn't think the bruschetta had enough flavor and the crema limone was just okay. However - the main dishes were excellent and very large and my wife's chocolate dessert was (in her words) "amazing." I am a big guy and couldn't finish all of my pasta. Another visit will definitely be in the plans for entrees only - no appetizer or dessert(unless my wife insists on the cake again!).
FV: 8/10
For the large portion sizes, the price OOP would have been fine - fairly reasonable by WDW standards.
AT: 8.5/10
It is nestled far in the back of the park - so it was not busy at all - many empty tables only 3 days before Christmas. It was quiet, very nicely decorated, and we were seated within 5 minutes of checking in. Our server, Youness, was wonderful and not pushy at all.