On 8/9 4 day cruise. Yes pirate menu in dining room on the 4 day - don't know about 3 day. No Pirate buffet after fireworks though. You will find out your rotation when you get your keys that are placed in the fish extender outside your room. Note, you can request specific rotations by calling
DCL. If you have a specific day you want to do Palo you can request your least favorite dining room that day. No guarantee but I have always gotten what I requested.