7 day Caribbean Cat 3s are usually around 5700-6900 when I've booked. I usually travel during less peak times, and try to book as far out as possible.
They offered me a Cat 3 on a 12 nt Baltic for I think around $12K.
Were those Caribbean prices total, or per person? I have no recollection of what we paid for our Cat 3 in 6/04, but we were offered on on the 7 night Western in 4/08 and the total for 4 people (ages of kids in sig below) was a little over $10K. We were paying roughly $6K for our cat 4 so we stuck with that.
We also priced out a Cat 3 for 12/2010 and for 4 people it's $10K again.
On the 5 night Magic last September (the filler between the panama repo and drydock) we paid just about $6K for 5 people in a Cat 2. We did book that 19 months out and it as hurricane season (we got to go right through one in an attempt to get to
Castaway Cay), and pretty much all schools were back in session or starting that week. So it was a pretty undesirable time to sail so I am sure that kept the price really low.
We're on the 7/6 Baltic in a Cat 3 and for 4 people we're paying $18K. We haven't added our baby in yet, but I imagine it will be just about $20K after we do.
So I guess I am not shocked by $14K for a Cat 3 for Alaska, but given that we're only paying $4K more for an additional night and in the Baltic where there are only 4 sailings, not the whole summer, it seems a little higher than I would have liked.
Oh, one last thing, I don't pay attention to when they say they stop taking faxed requests cause we faxed in our request last September for summer 2010 and everyone said they had already stopped accepting them. Well my husband sent it anyway, which I didn't know, and lo and behold we got a call for our midship Cat 3 on the Baltic cruise. So I think it's still worth a shot to send it in. You may not get anything, but who knows, you might. I remember last year some people said they had faxed in a request a year or 2 before we did and they never got a call, yet our request had been sent in maybe 2 weeks earlier and we did get a call.