2006 October DisneyWorld Trip *Complaints*

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's is no doubt in my mind that Disney is slipping. I have 20 trips under my belt all through the years and it's not the same as their earlier years. This doesn't mean I will quit going, but there is a difference all the way around with Disney, now. My last trip was late September, early October this year with the free dining plan.

First, in the beginning Disney would use their third shift to do all maintenance aspects of the parks. They kept up with everything pretty good back when. It was a rare instance when something wasn't working right during park hours. I even heard that back when Disney would do touch up painting; so, you would never see peeling paint, scratches down to the wood, etc. on the buildings and rides all done on third shift. In the old days, they would have taken the new carpet out of the monorails, use a glue remover, and re-do the whole thing right if there was a mistake/problem with it.

Also, I believe in the early years people working for Disney felt they were special like it was an honor to work for the company. It didn't matter what level of employment it was; they felt good about working for Disney. You could tell by the smiles and attitudes that flowed out of everyone. Now, it seems more of a job to most Disney employees or a resume builder. It's not the same mind-set, anymore. Also, Disney is doing more outsourcing these days for various jobs.

I'm a clean buff on the homefront. I keep my home very clean most of the time. Again, in the early years I felt Disney was doing the same thing. I don't feel that way, now. You wouldn't see a speck of dust in the old days, anywhere. The restrooms were immaculate, as an example.

I know everything I mentioned has to do with staffing issues. The lean and mean theories of today have caused Disney to fall in the same mode as other companies. Disney has to answer to their stockholders. It's much more business oriented with the bottom line profits, etc., now. We live more in the present with short-term goals rather than the long-term. To compete with their stockholders, they need to keep costs down; so, therefore, the quality has to go down with less staffing and cheaper wages considering inflation.

Noone will like hearing this (I'm ready to be flamed), but I believe people put in less than an honest day's work, now then in the years gone by. We are in an ethics and morales crisis, now. All of this is going to impact the Disney World we see today.

In regards to specifics, you are not forced to use the monorails to MK. You can travel there by ferry boat, etc. If you didn't notice the smell right off then I suppose you are stuck the first time. If you did smell it right off I wouldn't enter the monorail car. I would wait for the next one or use alternate transportation if it bothers me enough. Next, there has to be more than one place where you can get a slushy in a park. The dining plan debate will go on and on. Some feel the dining plan restaurants are more full now especially during the off-season times. By having more people in the restaurants with the dining plan the wait staff gets more tip money overall; because, there are more customers. Everyone can tip more, if service calls for it. The included gratuity from the plan can be added to for deserving wait staff. If the wait staff doesn't like the new dining plan, then quit and go somewhere more desirable to work. There are park restaurants not on the plan; get a transfer. Some people feel the wait staff is preying on the Disney customer on the dining plan by complaining; so, they will get an extra tip. My understanding is there are some inadequencies with non-own Disney restaurants on the plan mostly in World Showcase. Supposedly, this has to do with the agreements these restaurants have under contract with Disney to be included in the plan. Supposedly, the restaurant gets half of the bill from Disney for plan customers. Now, the restaurant is turning it around on the wait staff and giving them half of their tip. This is really a Disney problem with these non-owned Disney restaurants and we are caught in the business decision. Some say a half tip on a more expensive meal still averages out to a decent tip, anyway. Most people over order on the plan and/or pick more expensive items than what they would do normally out of pocket; so, the tip gets boosted that way. It's been said that waiters will point you in these directions to pad the bill and get a better tip like choosing a more expensive appetizer, etc. These non-owned Disney restaurants are not forced to be part of the plan. I think the wait staff has to start voicing their opinions to their bosses, etc. at the restaurants, not us. To take it out on the consumer is unprofessional. If our waiters were good we tipped more on the free dining plan. We skipped dessert a few times and we compensated on the tip extra to make up the difference on the total bill for it. Personally, I've been on the plan a few times and I still haven't had any bad waiters.

As long as Disney keeps bringing in the travellers, you will be hard pressed to get them to change their current policies; unless, it involves a safety issue. most people will acknowledge that many companies were better in the old days. It's a changing world out there and we need to adjust. If it gets too bad, I will change my vacation destination. I don't need an "A" place for vacation, but I want go to a "C-" place, either. There's still more good than bad at Disney; so, I still keep going there. Actually, I think we should be more concerned with all the time shares Disney is pushing, now. This is my two-cents worth.
 
I think I'm gonna have to side with one of the earlier posters in this thread who said that many of you who have done disney repeatedly have simply gotten used to the service.

I travel all over the country, and I deal primarily with people in the hospitality industry, and I can tell you that the service we received from the Cast Members last week was some of the best service that I have ever received.

Cast Members were attentive to our needs, they were polite, and engaging in conversation, and they did little things that we never expected.

If Disney has changed, they have done so because our culture has changed and the workplace has changed. Even still...they are heads and shoulders above those in the same industry. I felt like a welcomed "guest" of Disney last week (no, I didnt win anything in the YOMD promotion).

The only thing I'll agree with is the smell of the monorails.
 
See, i think many of you are getting my intentions wrong. You are reading it one way and doing a bizzare interpritation of my complaint.


The monorail: It's not a make or break thing. I delt with the odor, many times. I am just asounded that a company that once prided themselves in legendary customer service would ALLOW this to continue. Turning a blind eye.
Like an earlier and much wizer poster said. The OLD disney would have shut down a monorail, gutted it, reglued and carpeted the thing. It was, at one point, an apple in walts eye. He felt it was the future of travel. Now its a smell vision of year 2050!

Not to offend anyone but lets twist a popular phrase of our time.
WWWD (What would Walt DO?)?

As for grumpy cast members. Yeah, i do EXPECT them to be a cut above.
They willingly go into the hospitality biz, they work for one of the MOST recognizable names in hospitality and are lucky enough to have a job there...and my quite pricey admission is paying thier salary...they need to fake it if it aint real.

Days past i remember CM's going out of thier way for me...now i feel like i am IN thier way.
Many others have noted the shift...so i know i "aint smokin crack".

More than anything i was posting what i saw as a heartbroken fan.

Positives on my trip:
1. Everest Kicks booty
2. Photopass is one of the greatest ideas they have had in a long time.
3. R&R Coaster is still the best
4. More Drops on TOT
5. Indy Jones still looks fresh as if its thier 1st time
6. 60 minute standby waits were really 15 minutes 9 times out of 10.
7. Mission Space....what can i say...its simply amaaaaaazing!


My complaints about Si-Fi come from Mega experience with that place.
I've been to that place at least 15 times. I can accept a missing tomato, a charred chicken finger. A slip of of a CM. But this time the ENTIRE experience was SOOO bad it stuck out. Every aspect of our SiFi experience was a disaster.
This year was our 1st 50's Cafe experience. It was fun, and the food was good. It was worth the 100.00 tab (paid by CC not disney dining). We got our $ worth.

My original email seems to have been experienced by others that have seen the decline too.

My feeling is not anger, but somber...like when you just leave a funeral.

My FAMILY had a blast, but the adults all noticed many things, and my sisters family (1st disney trip ever) even pointed out some things.....including the Monorail Odor.

Dennis
 
ive used DDP as well and never had bad service. You get whacked 18% tip right from the gitgo so how can CM's complain when typically you get 10-15%. If they are not getting that then where does my 18% go? As for the smell of the monorail, we did not encounter it although we only rode from Contemperary to MK.
 

I love to read the boards to re-live my very first trip to Disney in June 2006. The one thing I did not remember (until I started reading this thread) was the funky smelling monorail!! :rotfl: The experience was so traumatic that I do believe I blocked it from my mind!

It did indeed smell EXACTLY like a stable!! The first time we rode one we were embarressed when others came on board. We absolutely did not want anyone to think we were the funky ones!! Only to discover that that is just what they smell like ALL THE TIME!!
 
Denicio said:
I am not there to put smiles on thier faces.
Heaven forbid you actually put forth a little effort to make somebody elses' day a little brighter. No matter where I go, WDW or otherwise, I always try to make sure the employees I encounter know they are appreciated. While it seems that other people make sure the employees know that they are only there to service said customers needs. Ever seen the movie: "Pay it Forward"?
My family of 5 shelled out over 5000.00 for this past trip....and i am supposed to make thier day?
Ahhhh...entitlement.
 
I think one of the problems that the OP has is that this isn't the Disney that Walt envisioned (or What would Walt do?), but unfortunately times have changed. While Disney might be able to run Disney the way Walt had dreamed of, the reality is that if Disney did that, many of us wouldn't be able to afford to go to Disney. It's just not cost effective. The bottom line is - it comes down to the bottom line. Everyone is always looking for the affordable ways to do Disney. Every day I see posts asking where is the cheapest place to buy tickets; which restaurants to go to in order to get the most out of the dining plan; when do you think they'll do the free dining again, who gives what for free if my child is wearing a birthday button (even though his b-day isn't for another 3 months) has anyone seen a code yet for January, February, March, etc....
So what is it people want? A Disney that's affordable enough to go to for repeat visits OR a Disney so magical and special that a family can only afford to go there once in a life time? I think Disney does a great job of balancing those two goals.
 
kevw67 said:
ive used DDP as well and never had bad service. You get whacked 18% tip right from the gitgo so how can CM's complain when typically you get 10-15%. If they are not getting that then where does my 18% go? As for the smell of the monorail, we did not encounter it although we only rode from Contemperary to MK.


What the restaurant prints out for the guest, and what the restaurant gets reimbursed from Disney are 2 different things. What the server gets is 18% of the "reimbursed amount" not 18% of the check. The reason the tip prints out on the bottom of the check is so that you're aware that a tip is already included. The reimbursed amount is a set amount, no matter how much or how little you actually order. So if the restaurant gets reimbursed $10.00 per Adult TS credit (and I'm just using this number off the top of my head, I have no idea how the amount we pay is actually divied up between table service/counter service/and snack) then $8.47 will go to the restaurant for food and $1.53 will go to the wait staff for the tip.
 
We should get the wine tasters from the Food and Wine festival to ride the monorail and decide if it's "elephant house with subtle goat shed undertones" or "Memphis street latrine with a perky dog park fire hydrant bouquet."

That smell (which to me was "elephant house at the zoo") wasn't present on my trip on Halloween 04 or trips prior to that, but definitely jumped out at me for the first time last September.

I've never seen staff at Sci Fi interact with the movies, though. I'd probably find that a little obnoxious -- I wasn't always paying rapt attention to it and if somebody screamed next to me I'd spill my drink or something.

My sister, who went to the first Not So Scary Halloween Party did say that it was far more elaborate -- there were dried colorful leaves blowing down the streets that had been absolutely immaculate and undecorated just hours before. She was amazed at the park's transformation in a mere couple of hours. When we went back a couple of years ago for Halloween she was saddened that that part of the evening had been abandoned. It was my first time and I had a blast, but I suppose it's only natural to notice slips in quality from previously wonderful experiences.
 
Denicio said:
but i felt like kmart had taken over the parks and i was getting raped.

Not to single out the OP... but honestly, what is it with this list recently? I keep seeing people comparing less than exceptional quality customer service with being 'raped'. Believe me, as a rape survivor I can tell you that there is no comparison.

Please try to be at least a little bit empathetic when choosing your wording. OK, so you had a less than wonderful experience. Why not simply say so, without the definitely not humorous over-exaggerations? :confused3
 
popcorn::
I'm glad we're staying at CR for the first time ever this Fall. I've got to smell the Monorail, as I really don't recall anything. I know what my Dad's boat smells like (1963 Chris Craft Holiday :cloud9: ), I love the smell of a good steak dinner, DW's favorite perfume, and I can tell what brand of .22 ammunition someone is using from the smell (International style prone and 3-position). I just can't remember a Monorail smell...
We bought the DDP, so it will be interesting to see how it goes.
 
PADisneyCouple- That was so funny. :rotfl2: I went to WDW twice this year and as a coincidence during some of the same days as Denicio (Oct.6-9). I rode the monorail many times since I spent most of my time at EPCOT for the food festival and the Magic Kingdom. I never noticed any smell. There should be something wrong with my nose. I agree with a couple of posters and the comments that maybe because we go to Disney frequently, we don't see it the same way as we did the first couple of times and we notice other details that first time vistors do not notice.

Denicio, I read that the reason why you cannot take the bus directly to Downtown Disney anymore is because some people were parking there and taking the bus to go to the parks to avoid paying parking. That was creating many problems and they had to change this.

I agree that things are getting more expensive every year. The WDW AP used to be more expensive than the Disneyland AP but that one also increased in price.
 
DizzKneeGeek said:
Heaven forbid you actually put forth a little effort to make somebody elses' day a little brighter. No matter where I go, WDW or otherwise, I always try to make sure the employees I encounter know they are appreciated. While it seems that other people make sure the employees know that they are only there to service said customers needs. Ever seen the movie: "Pay it Forward"?
Ahhhh...entitlement.

You wrote EXACTLY how I feel and I thank you. :thumbsup2
 
SMELL? I have a super-sensitive nose and noticed nothing when we rode in January.
 
As a cast member, I have advice for those who have problems with other cast members:

GET A MANAGER.

Seriously. Get a manager. None of the corporates are going to care about the third level peons that are taking your food orders. If you have a problem with someone not giving you -at the very least - adequate service, report it to a manager. Problems don't get resolved if you leave them alone until you get home.
 
Hey Denicio,

Just a few thoughts as I feel you have some legitimate complaints.

1. The biggest issue to me is the DDP. Although on its face it may have seem great to start but I think the real colors and problems are shining through. First the restaurants are packed. Forgot about any spontaniety in your eating. To me that ruined alot of the fun of walking past a restaurant and being intriguied and saying you know what lets give it a shot. That also means that the servers are pushed to the max number of tables and are doing a huge turnover, so no wonder service is declined. Finally the menus have become bland and pretty much universal. With the DDP the horse may be out of the barn but I wish there was some way we could organize a memo or petition here and get it to the higher ups at disney.

BTW How were the crowds when you were there I am going next year on the exact week you went?
 
Matt'sMom said:
Not to single out the OP... but honestly, what is it with this list recently? I keep seeing people comparing less than exceptional quality customer service with being 'raped'. Believe me, as a rape survivor I can tell you that there is no comparison.

Please try to be at least a little bit empathetic when choosing your wording. OK, so you had a less than wonderful experience. Why not simply say so, without the definitely not humorous over-exaggerations? :confused3
I noticed this too and wondered why no one had mentioned it (just got to the thread this morning). I find these "rape" comments classless.
 
I just found this thread.
I had to comment about the frisbees at Sci Fi. We have eaten there numerous times on past trips. I don't think my DDs have ever gotten frisbees. I think that I would remember because I would have to pack them around all day. (We normally eat lunch there.) Maybe they have gotten them and we just left them to avoid packing them around. :confused3 I don't know. I was just commenting because I don't remember frisbees.
 
Devil_Dog99 said:
But to EXPECT 100% satisfaction 100% of the time is a bit unrealistic.


I'm sorry Devil Dog, but it is to be expected. It doesn't matter what type of business you are in. If you don't deliver 100% satisfaction 100% of the time the customer will start looking elsewhere. We all drop a ton of cash when we go to Disney and our investment should give us a good return. I know beyond a shadow of a doubt that if I deliver a bad product to any of my customers I risk losing that customers business. Disney has long been able to corner the market for great family vacations, but if they don't stop delivering a sub par product, Universal is just around the corner.
 
Laurie from Iowa--as an Iowan also just wanted to say hi! :wave: We will be there next month as well and I will tryo to make the CMs' days special too! We have cards and treats all ready to hand out to them! :sunny:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom