We like the following character meals:
Chef Mickey's at the Contemporary Resort - Mickey Mouse, Minnie Mouse, Goofy, Pluto, & Donald character meal; characters at breakfast & lunch; buffet - we prefer breakfast to dinner; very cool atmosphere with the monorail running through
Cinderella's Royal Table in the Magic Kingdom - Princess character meal at breakfast & lunch (Cinderella is in the lobby) & the Fairy Godmother & the mice (Suzy & Perla) are there for dinner; preplated breakfast, order from the menu for lunch & dinner; very wonderful atmosphere!
Crystal Palace in the Magic Kingdom - Winnie the Pooh & Friends character meal; characters at breakfast, lunch, & dinner; buffet with lots of yummy items not normally on buffets; the interior of the restaurant is lovely
Garden Grill at Epcot - Mickey Mouse, Pluto, Chip, & Dale dressed in farmer attire character meal for lunch & dinner; family-style; neat atmosphere w/ the slowly revolving floor
Liberty Tree Tavern - Minnie Mouse, Goofy, Pluto, Chip, & Dale dressed in colonial attire for dinner; family-style; good character interaction
Other family-fun restaurants, but w/o characters, that we like are Ohana at the Poly and Whispering Canyon Cafe at the Wilderness Lodge.
We've also done the Princess Storybook dinner at Akershus in Norway at Epcot - the character interaction was good (Cinderella was marvelous!), the interior was lovely - very "country castle", but we we didn't care for the food - it wasn't that we weren't prepared to try Norwegian dishes - the food just wasn't very good - my DH's entree was cold, my pasta was dry & the sauce was overcooked. We'd probably try it again (everyone has an "off" night), just, after we've scheduled our favs & then added some new places we want to try, there's no "room" left in our dining schedule.
We have a little boy and a little girl, so we schedule a variety of character meals. If I schedule too many princess meals, I start feeling guilty!

However, if we had two little girls, I'd probably do either CRT or Princess Storybook and 1900 Park Faire (dinner) and then Chef Mickey's, Crystal Palace, and Liberty Tree Tavern or Garden Grill - depdending on how long our vacation was going to be.
Have fun planning!
