1st and 10 on the Disney Magic Western Caribbean 2/4/12

allears

"If I were not upon the sea..." I'd want to be!
Joined
Jul 20, 2002
Messages
2,864
This was my 10th Disney cruise and my DP’s first. I wanted to do an overview report of our impressions of our February 4th sailing of the Magic, which was the ten year anniversary of my first sailing on her. So here goes, a kind of outline:

Travel: We flew down the day before, via South West and took Magical Express to the resort. We played at Downtown Disney and Disney Quest in the afternoon and had dinner with a couple we met through the boards at Boma. We retired early (as we left home at 3:45 am that morning) at our room at the Pop Century.

Had a private car pick us up the next morning and got to the port for our arrival time of 11 am. Super smooth, quick check in and on board by noon! So great to be back!

We used the DCL bus back to the airport on debarkation day and after a bit of a wait for our 3 pm flight, were early landing at home and met with snow. All went like clockwork!

The ship: I have read some of the isolated posts about the Magic looking worn and tired, we couldn’t disagree more! She looked every bit as beautiful as she did ten years ago and every time I’ve sailed her! Yes there were some patches of rust, but they were being scraped and painted constantly. She is truly a classic and so very well maintained. Everything was in working order, looked clean and fresh. My DP, who has never cruised before, thought she was spectacular.

Dining: We had second seating and a table for two. The food and service were excellent and we ate almost non-stop the entire week! Palo brunch on Sunday, dinner or Tuesday and high tea on Thursday. The food and experience were beyond excellent, simply superb!!! Ciao Romano was our server and he is the BEST!!! We enjoyed Topsiders, the quick service outlets as well as ice cream, pretty much every time we passed the station!

Entertainment: The shows were outstanding! Saw Villains Tonight, for the first time and loved it! Very cool, very funny! DP was super impressed by the quality of the shows and enjoyed all of them as well as the entertainers.

We had three acts that I’ve not seen before, Danny Buckler, a magician from the UK, Buckets and Boards, a duo who played plastic buckets, did comedy and music, Michael Dubois a juggler and finally John Charles, who is always great! We made sure to catch all of their performances and enjoyed each one.

Spent a good bit of time each night at Rockin’ Bar D – Tisa was the hostess and was AWESOME! We danced, participated in some of the game shows and just had a great time!

The deck parties were incredible, especially the Pirate Party! We were in full pirate costumes and had a lot of fun that night. And what is better than fireworks at sea!!!!

Weather: All of the days were pretty nice – with the exception of Sunday at Key West, where it rained non-stop. Castaway Cay day started out a little cloudy and a bit rainy, but by 12:30 turned out to be spectacular! We enjoyed a lot of time in the sun by the adult pool pretty much every day.

Ports: Key West is one of my favorites – despite the rain. We walked around a bit and visited the Ship Wreck Historium. We did the island tour at Grand Cayman, and the day was beautiful. Spent some time shopping in Cozumel. Castaway Cay day was great! Explored the island a bit, spent time at Serenity Bay, where we also had lunch. On the way back to the ship, did a little shopping and played at Pelican Plunge!

All in all – as excellent and magical as all of my previous voyages! And it successfully sold my DP on future cruises! I was worried that I had oversold the experience to him, but he found everything to be just as great as I described, so very many times.
We’ve booked out next cruise for the same time next year, on the Fantasy. We are eager to check out the amazing new ship and know that it will be fun, but I’m kind of thinking I’ll miss the Magic! We’ll see.

Please feel free to hit us up with any questions or details we might not have covered!:confused3

Oh and woooohoooo! I’ve hit platinum!!!!!:banana:
 
Thanks for posting!:goodvibes
What kind of stateroom did you have? How was it - location, comfort etc?
THANKS!

We had a Cat 5C, ocean view with a veranda. We were on deck 5, the first room on the port side of the aft sections of staterooms. It was very nice, quite comfortable and we liked it very much. And it was a great location for getting everywhere on the ship, not that any place on the ship is hard to get to.
 
You're info is great!!!

I am cruising on the Magic next Feb....I know, it's a year away. But, is it ever too early to start getting excited about Disney:rotfl2:

You mentioned you had a private car pick you up? What car company was that? I am looking into a cruise with Disney for later 2013 with my mom and am hoping to get a car service. I only know of 1. Any other info would be greatly appreciated:thumbsup2

Glad you had a great trip!!!

Jenn
 

You're info is great!!!

I am cruising on the Magic next Feb....I know, it's a year away. But, is it ever too early to start getting excited about Disney:rotfl2:

You mentioned you had a private car pick you up? What car company was that? I am looking into a cruise with Disney for later 2013 with my mom and am hoping to get a car service. I only know of 1. Any other info would be greatly appreciated:thumbsup2

Glad you had a great trip!!!

Jenn

This time we used Happy Limo, they were very good. I have used Tiffany Town Car in the past, they were a bit more expensive this time.
 
Great overview on the cruise I also couldn't agree more the ship is in excellent condition, they can't fix everything they are on a schedule as to when they redo paint and other upgrades, just as you would do in your own home, I am the one who commented about the live band during that sailing, if you have been on the magic 10 times you have to admit that the "Right Stuff" was a little more talented, I'm not saying they were unlistenable ( if thats a word) I just thought they were lacking something. Any ways maybe we will see you on the Fantasy next we also booked for the same time, first veranda on the front of the ship, we are non smokers so its nice we can enjoy the veranda. Congrats on Platinum we will be Gold! next year were also excited but Platinum that Cool! By chance you dis board name allears, were you the one with the mouse ears on the whole cruise?
Tim
 
Great overview on the cruise I also couldn't agree more the ship is in excellent condition, they can't fix everything they are on a schedule as to when they redo paint and other upgrades, just as you would do in your own home, I am the one who commented about the live band during that sailing, if you have been on the magic 10 times you have to admit that the "Right Stuff" was a little more talented, I'm not saying they were unlistenable ( if thats a word) I just thought they were lacking something. Any ways maybe we will see you on the Fantasy next we also booked for the same time, first veranda on the front of the ship, we are non smokers so its nice we can enjoy the veranda. Congrats on Platinum we will be Gold! next year were also excited but Platinum that Cool! By chance you dis board name allears, were you the one with the mouse ears on the whole cruise?
Tim

Thanks Tim!

And you're right, they are constantly plugging away at keeping the Magic lookout great.

The Right Stuff! I couldn't remember the name, and yes they were awesome! The best ever. And nope, Heatwave was not as good.

Nope, I'm a guy, but I did see the lady you were talking about, with the ears on all of the time.

Look forward to sailing with you next year. We have an ocean view on deck two this time.
 
Sorry I shouldn't assume, do you always cruise at this time of the year? We are excited about going on the Fantasy we stayed in Canaveral to see the Dream on Sunday it was Huge, But it think we will miss the Magic also.
Tim
 
Thanks for the update. We are sailing 4 weeks after you - same itinerary! Good to see you left her for us in great shape. Thanks again!
 
Sorry I shouldn't assume, do you always cruise at this time of the year? We are excited about going on the Fantasy we stayed in Canaveral to see the Dream on Sunday it was Huge, But it think we will miss the Magic also.
Tim

No worries, I thought it was funny!

I have sailed mostly in February. It's nice to get away from the cold in NJ and the weather on the cruise is usually great.

I'm very much looking forward to seeing and sailong on the fantasy, but I can see myself missing the Magic.
 
Thanks for the update. We are sailing 4 weeks after you - same itinerary! Good to see you left her for us in great shape. Thanks again!

Lol! You're most welcome. She should be in even better shape, they were working very hard to keep her gleaming!
 
I was worried about sailing on the magic for our first cruise since the ship is a little older, but now I am more at ease. If you say the ship is great...I believe you, lol!!
 
I was worried about sailing on the magic for our first cruise since the ship is a little older, but now I am more at ease. If you say the ship is great...I believe you, lol!!

You really don't have to worry, she's in terrific shape and maintenance is ongoing and pretty much non-stop. Sure there will be patches of rust here and there, but chances are they will be dealt with in no time. In fact our balcony and the ones in our area of the ship had some rust issues, and we saw the maintenace folks working in that section all wee. In fact by the end of the week we got a letter and phone call telling us they would be working on our balacony while we were in Castaway Cay. Sure enough that afternoon they had scraped and primed the rust patches and I'm sure they were painted in time for the next guests.

They are on a never ending cycle of painting and refreshing and the ship always looks great to me.

Enjoy!
 

GET UP TO A $1000 SHIPBOARD CREDIT AND AN EXCLUSIVE GIFT!

If you make your Disney Cruise Line reservation with Dreams Unlimited Travel you’ll receive these incredible shipboard credits to spend on your cruise!














Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top