I havent done 1900 but have done GF Cafe several times. The last 2 times I stayed at the GF, I ate there every morning, so total I have eaten there 21 times. I have made an ADR for DH and I to eat there again in August, just 1 time this time since we arent staying at the GF and theres other places I wanna eat at. Anyways, I love their food. The frozen chocolate cappacino's is like a drink made in heaven. Even DH loves them and he usually hates frozen cappacinos. I usually get the Mickey waffle, which is pretty good. Filling but good. At least its filling to me anyway. It also depends on if you want a character meal. If you had kids, I would prob say do 1900. But since its just the 2 of you, that depends on if you want characters around you or not.