I'm prob the 'most vocal' about using Yahoo Groups. I'll jump in and hope others will share their comments - concerns and derogatory remarks (derogatory remarks will be graded).
I have experience in using both sites with past cruises they compliment each other very-very well.
Is the consensus to use the Yahoo Group site over this message board?
IMHO...NO! The Yahoo site was never intended to replace our DIS thread (period). It was created to be an extension of it. So the Yahoo site could not replace the DIS...the ability to post messages on Yahoo has been deactivated. A Moderator (Brenda and myself) could turn this back on - I don't recommend this...but would if the group wanted to.
Here are MY pro/con list (your mileage may vary - and that's...OK)
Pros for the DIS (items DIS is better at)
- The people on these boards are FANTASTIC!! Other boards I've been to...'some' people are not just cut-throat and cold-hearted - they are nasty. Again - some.
- The DIS has an ability to bring people together that are taking the same sailing or have common Disney travel goals. We get to meet more future friends - WOO HOO!
- Other forums within this web site are extremely helpful - Main
DCL, DL, photography, budget and WDW boards have been a wealth of information for me - what a blessing these forums are.
- You get to 'talk' Disney - does it get better than this.
Cons for DIS
- The DIS will close a thread at a moderators discretion or automatically when it reaches 'x' number of pages or posts (I can't remember what 'x' is - 250 pages seems to come to mind - anyone school me on this). Obviously from our 1,373 posts...nothing previously discussed/stated puts us 'at risk' of a Mod locking this thread - but... If closed...there is no reason we can't start a "part two" thread.
- Finding past information in a thread or forum...is cumbersome (for me).
- Posting pictures require you to upload them to an alternate site before posting them on a thread (Photobucket or a DIS site are a few - of many).
- DIS will block the posting of certain internet links. Obviously...they want you to use their services and not a competitor. I understand this...and because of the DIS (and the on-board credit)...I use and refer their sponsor...
Dreams Unlimited to book our Disney Cruises. Both DIS and DU have been fantastic for my family - hopefully yours as well. However...some of the sites they block have valuable information.
Pros for Yahoo (things Yahoo does better)
- Security...initial entry requires an invitation from a Moderator. And...a Moderate can 'deactivate an invite' - i.e., boot someone out. That being said...I've never 'kicked anyone off' - but we would if it were best for our group.
- It accepts file uploads from MS Office (Word, Excel, Power Point - etc). Files stored are titled, offer a preview of their content and are easy to share and locate.
- The Moderators can move database information directly into Excel - effortlessly (e.g. Organizing the Fish Extender lists and other fun - quickly and easily).
- ALL internet links can be posted.
- Pictures can be uploaded directly from your hard drive into a folder and shared - one step.
Cons for Yahoo
- It takes a little getting used to. You can get assistance from
on-line tutorials.
- start up and use with our group has gotten off to a slow start.
I haven't been to the Yahoo Group site for awhile but will make more of an effort if that is the preferred method for setting up plans, etc.
Thank you for your comment!!

I hope you will return to enjoy some time on our Yahoo site. If we all participate...this will be an AWESOME tool!!
It's my hopes all will participate on BOTH web sites. From past experience, a combination of DIS (daily talk) and Yahoo (secure storage of information) will allow us to share, plan and have a FANTASTIC Disney vacation.