Our ADRs were for 6:25 pm. We arrived slightly early and were seated quickly. The restaurant was quite busy and walk up diners were being turned away.
This is quite a controversial restaurant. You read so many conflicting opinions about San Angel Inn. I was looking forward to all our ADRs and this one was no exception. I was excited to eat here, so let's just say that I began the evening with a positive attitude...and NOTHING happened to change it...not even somewhat Grumpy, our server.
I would associate these menu offerings more with a Southwestern style grill Mexican food, think Sante Fe Mex, AZ Mex, lime, cilantro, rice, black beans, extensive use of a grill.
The atmosphere here is AMAZING. And yes, it is dark. Very dark. Like night time dark. This is purposeful. It is wonderful. I have had the privelege of eating in similar settings outside, at night, in Cabo San Lucas and San Antonio (I know, I know, Texas, not Mexico, but still...have you been there? Mexican influence is huge.). This atmosphere is well recreated. You could hardly read your menu, let alone see your food, there either. Honestly, I could see my food better AFTER I took a picture and saw the review on my camera.
The tables ARE close together. But I did not find this problematic. The tables were aligned point to point, like diamonds, not like a grid, if that makes sense, so line of sight and chair room helped with table spacing. I could see the wider pathways for the servers. They were strategic and generally, every table bordered a pathway on at least one side, if not two. So, more space there.
The restaurant is like a sunken dining room. You step down into it from the level that the rest of Mexico is. There is a wall that separates the restaurant from the market area. There are lights strung across the market area, lamp posts on the columns of the wall, some random wall sconces. You have one gas burning lamp for light on your table. Once the chips and dip come out, you literally can't see half the table. How about some pictures?
Here's the view of the market place from the restaurant. This is the wall..
Notice the men in matching blue jackets...that's the band that came out and played for a while. Very fun. I liked the music. I used to live in San Antonio, and it totally made me think of the Riverwalk area. College days...good times.
The wall continues around
In the opposite direction of the marketplace is the backdrop...an amazing mural of a volcano scene.
See, it's dark and the tables are close. I think I was blinding people with my flash...here is the Kodak Software adjusted picture
Again, more details...unadjusted
and ADJUSTED
Something about being in the dark translated into a more quiet restaurant, despite the table proximity and busy-ness.
Here are the chips and salsa:
The chips were fresh and the salsa was okay. I can be a salsa snob. I couldn't tell if this was fresh made salsa, or if was from a jar, honestly. It had good flavor, and was a high quality jarred salsa, if jarred, but I really couldn't tell if it had been "cooked" like jarred salsa is, or if it was fresh. Regardless, it has some heat, the build in your mouth kind, which I enjoyed, but it wasn't hot by any means.
These were THE BEST
One
Frozen Margarita - Lime, Strawberry, Mango or Fiesta Mix. DH had lime. And one
Margarita San Angel Inn - Tequila Sauza Gold, and triple sec.
After good reviews of the Ceviche, I wanted to order it, but was talked out of it by our server. He said it was raw seafood and seemed to really want to steer me clear of it. So I ordered the
Sopa Azteca - Traditional tortilla soup with avocado, cheese and pasilla pepper
which was okay. I could taste the fresh avocado in it. I love avocado. I've had too many amazing tortilla soups to be impressed with this, but I was caught off guard by the server's reluctance to just accept my original order.
DH ordered the
Nachos - Border creation of tortilla chips topped with red sauce, melted cheese, chorizo (Mexican sausage), jalapenos, tomatoes and sour cream
in part because he thought that DS might enjoy it. And here AGAIN, we find that an appetizer is not included in the DDP for a child.
The chips are buried underneath the toppings and you really have to work to separate the chips from all the cheeeeeese. These were tasty. Not normal, mind, but what is there to complain about super cheesy, spruced up chips?
DH and I both ordered
Combinacion Cozumel - Grilled beef tenderloin, marinated shrimp and roasted chayote served with spicy ranchero sauce, poblano pepper mashed potatoes and grilled veggies.
We both ordered the tenderloin medium. It was perfectly pink on the inside and warm throughout...an absolutely perfect medium. The meat almost melted in your mouth. The presentation included a fold over corn tortilla that was fully immersed in the ranchero sauce and formed a bed of sorts for the meat. I ate a bite of the tortilla, didn't care for it, and wondered if it was just there to help control the spread of the plated sauce. The shrimp were very good. Tender, not tough. I've read complaints of metallic tasting shrimp...fortunately, not this night. The potatoes were a little spicy, pretty tasty. The vegetables that were actually grilled, the red pepper and the summer squash of some sort (see the grill marks) were great. I wish that I just had more of those and could skip what had to be the frozen veggie mix also added to the plate.
DS ordered
Mahi Mahi - Grilled fillet of mahi mahi served with white rice, mixed veggies, and fresh fruit cocktail
DS LOVES salmon. He also likes tuna and red river trout. He likes fish with flavor. He tried DHs Mahi Mahi for the first time at WPC and liked it. The other child's menu choices looked like losers to me, and I knew that I would at least like the Mahi Mahi if DS didn't, and I could trade meat for fish, or at least we all could have some surf and turf between the 3 of us. The Mahi Mahi was cooked well. It was fully cooked and still moist, but seemed to lack any added seasonings, unless my taste buds were overwhelmed with my own. This fish was quite plain, not bland, just plain, getting most of it's flavor from the being grilled. It would be a sad dish on it's own, but was just fine when the turf was added.
DH and I ordered the
Flan de Vainilla: vanilla custard in syrup, topped with roasted almonds
which was weird. I don't know about those almonds on top...it did not add a pleasing crunch for me. I flicked them off and just ate the custard, which was okay. If you have had the coconut flan at CP, then you have eaten better flan than this at SAI. That said, it wasn't horrible, just not the best. In retrospect, and looking at the menus, I would ask for a smoothie instead, which I suppose I could have gotten anyway, according to our server at YCG because we paid OOP for the margaritas.
DS had the vanilla ice cream, which was like vanilla bean ice cream. It was tasty. It would have been a better finish to our meal for DH and I.
What can I say? I thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience here at SAI. And I would not hesitate to come here again. The atmosphere is wonderful. It is an excellent hideaway, step into another dimension kind of place and I'd eat my entree again any day of the week, but only grilled veggies please.