This has been fun reading through all the posts!
We have DS5 and DD3:
Josiah Matthew
and
Rachel Elizabeth
I love both--timeless and not particularly trendy. Josiah does end up with people callling him Joshua if they look too quickly, but he handles that like a trooper--"um...it's Josiah...like King Josiah in the Bible!"
If he decides someday to shorten it to Joe or something similar, I'll be ok with that but for now he is definately Josiah. He actually doesn't like it when some of his friends call him Joe and he corrects them. His little sister calls him "Siah" half the time though, and he doesn't mind that at all, and I, who was so against him having a nickname, thinks it's cute...go figure!
Rachel means little lamb which I dearly love. I call her that a lot, and she loves it. I "knew" from the start she was a girl but had the boys name already picked out.
Josiah would have been Miriam Susannah.
Rachel would have been Lucas Michael.
If we had happened to have three boys they would have been Josiah, Lucas, and Elijah. (a prophet, priest, and king
)
Runner up for girls are Lydia and Rebecca. (DH later nixed Rebecca only for the Becky nickname option.) Susannah is my great-aunt's name and we will definately use that for the middle name next time.
I totally agree about not telling people before birth what your names are! Too many comments, and once they are here most (!) people will keep quiet if they don't like it!
We ended up with an Old Testament first name, and a New Testament middle name and thought that was neat. We don't really tell people that though and it's fun to watch a few relatives figure that out years later (Of course, they always think they are telling us like we didn't know!
)