As a former fastpass "runner" I can tell you that I felt much more rushed trying to move from one place to another under this new system than I ever did under the old one when trying to make fastpass+ appointments and dining reservations.
I felt very rushed on our last trip which was in November. Locked-in is actually the perfect word for how I felt .
I absolutely agree. That is how we felt too. The only thing I liked about FP+ was not having to leave my family upon park entry to make that first FP run of the day, and that was pretty great-- but I would gladly give it up and take that morning run back to have regular FP again. Towards the end of the week, we gave up trying to run place to place for FP+, and just relied on the old system unless FP+ happened to be convenient. Now, there is no more ability to do that.
But if we already have our FP+ appointment and our dining reservations set, then why would there be a rush? We know where we want to be and when...
We go at least once a year (or we did until this year), and I spent 3 hours at home tweaking FP+ to be sure to get it where I thought we would be in the park at any given time of the day. It didn't work. I thought I had a good idea of where we would be when as we are regular visitors, but we still found ourselves having to rush to criss-cross the park to make our FP+ times. Planning your day 60 days in advance is very difficult- and don't count on being able to change your times on
MDE in the parks either. MDE flat out glitched and didn't work much at all for us in the parks. Now that FP+ is for everyone, I think the times are going to be like ADRs even if MDE does work in the parks. With everyone having to guess what they want to do 60 days in advance or first thing when they hit a park, there isn't going to be the availability to change. You are truly going to be LOCKED in.
Instead of being able to pull FPs as your day goes on and depending on the areas where your day takes you, you are absolutely locked into certain times. There is no more going to tomorrow land, seeing the line for Space Mountain is 40 minutes, but you can get a FP that kicks in a hour later, and grabbing the FP and getting other things in Tommorrowland done while you wait for the FP to kick in. Now, lets say you had plans to do Fantasyland and the Circus area and then move over to Tomorrowland to do Space Mountain, so you planned your FP+ for when you thought you would get over there... but it turned out the line for Pooh and another couple of attractions was longer than you expected, your child wanted to ride Small World twic,e you decided to stop and meet Peter Pan, it took you forever to drag your youngest out of the Dumbo play area and suddenly, you are not quite ready to head over to Tomorrowland because you have more of Fantasyland to do- but that FP+ time is looming over you, and it is your only time of the day to do Space Mountain without a line and you have no opportunity to send someone to get a fast pass to do it later and give you more time. In current times, you have to drop everything and book it over there to use your FP+. In prior times, you could monitor when the FPs kicked in and time it as your day progressed, or you could grab FPs and if the time didn't turn out to work for you, you could find a family and give them those FPs (which always made people happy) and grab new FP for a better time for you. That's over-- The term LOCKED in the commercial is very accurate- WDW is LOCKING you into what they want.
Here is an example of something that happened on our trip. DD spotted Sophia and that was suddenly the most important thing to her for the day. We got in line, 3 groups before the line got cut off, and the line didn't really look that huge but as we stood there it became clear (as verified by a CM) that the line was almost an hour long. This was going to cause us trouble making our Star Tours FP+ time before the window expired which was where we were headed when Sophia suddenly became the most important thing to DD. We couldn't ride Star Tours and come back because the Sophia line was cut off. We couldn't catch Sophia in her later meet and greet and wait in a line that long again because we had our day scheduled with an ADR and show times for B&B and Indy, and by the time we did that, Sophia would be done for the day. Couldn't get the FP+ changed on MDE because after multiple glitches it told us there was nothing available the rest of the day for Star Tours (and then when I tried to give up and make it for something else- it would not let me). So, I grabbed our KTTW cards, went down to Star Tours, and found paper FPs available for 40 minutes out. Grabbed the paper fast passes (which can no longer be done) and went back to Sophia. Finished Sophia and went back to Star Tours and used the FPs. With no more FP-, either I would have had to have dragged DD out of the Sophia line and told her she could not meet her, or we would have taken our chances on stand by as we couldn't make FP+. We no longer have the ability to pull a FP- based on our day.
Also, I think where a lot of times people would NOT pull FPs because they would get to a certain ride and find they really didn't need them (at least I know that is what we did- if the line was 30 minutes or less, we generally just got in it)- now everyone feels compelled to pull and have 3 FP+. As such, where you used to find FP available, now everyone is going to LOCK in early, so the availability day of is going to be extremely limited. Even if MDE works in the parks, I don't think being able to make changes is going to be likely because where you used to have a situation were some people had 1 FP, some had none- now everyone is holding 3 from the outset.