I just wanted to mention that I was also debating about the pirate room. I originally booked a standard, but changed it a month or so later to the pirate room. I decided that the $150 extra was worth it for our 7 night stay, plus this trip is a honeymoon for my husband and I, although we are bringing my son because it just wouldn't be the same without him, and I would feel bad leaving him at home while I go to WDW. From what I read, people who did not like the pirate room for the extra money were more concerned about saving money than having the pirate theme. Some also complained about the location of the pirate rooms, being the furthest from the main pool and dining areas. People who enjoyed the pirate theme were pirate fans or had kids who were, and did not mind the extra money for the rooms because the theme was more important to them. Just thought I'd share! And in 4 days I will be able to tell you how I like the pirate room versus a standard!
Counting down the days...