My wife and I went there on my b-day, August 11.
Food, EXCELLENT. Some of the best food, if not THE best food at WDW, IMHO
That said, my b-day visit was not so good.
My wife asked to be by the window for the fireworks, made the PS weeks ahead of time and asked for this mentioned my 30th. We get there, and 'we'll take you back here to the wine room where it is quiet'. Well, I don't care about noise, but fine, we can get up and go outside to watch the fireworks. We do get by a window and see the water pagent and the full moon, that is nice.
Waitress takes our drink order, a bottle of wine and sushi appitizer. That comes pretty quick, she eventually gets our dinner order, wife has pork and I get the filet.
We finish the wine, order two apple martini's.
The table next to us gets their food rather quickly, we do not. Finally it comes, Jill's looks great, I cut into mine and it's still mooing. We send it back. Steak number two comes out. I cut into the middle this time, MOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Take this one back, in the meantime we're going to watch the fireworks.
Yay, explosions in the sky. Go back in, manager brings me my dinner this time (Jill is done at this point, didn't think about having her photograph me eating alone, but I wanted her to have a hot meal!) This one is finally done right. I eat, it's good. Waitress comes back, 'for the trouble we're buying the martinis' Now, I'm grateful for this, but back at home, if I sent back a $33 filet more than once, the manager buys the meal. But, we were on vacation so I didn't want to dwell on it.
Will we go back, probably. I do plan on writing a letter to the manager though, when I pay $150+ for dinner, I expect good service, and it was really lacking this time :/
darren