We've been to all of them, but voted for Le Cellier. The cheese soup is too salty to me, but I love their tomato stack appetizer, filet with mushroom risotto, and any of their desserts.
Le Cellier is usually one of our favorite meals at WDW, but this last trip (Dec '07) I found a new favorite in Tutto Italia. We never liked Alfredos, but Tutto Italia is REALLY good! I was sitting next to a couple from New York and the man really didn't want to be there and was making no secret of it. Apparently he was Italian and had never liked Alfredos either. I couldn't help but laugh at his face when his meal finally came. He looked like he was in Heaven. His wife told me that he is very picky about his Italian food and he laughed and made the comment that 'this is just like my grandma made". The whole time he was eating his appetizer platter, pasta entree, and dessert, he was looking longingly at mine. I finally laughed and offered him a bite of my fish and he got embarrassed and said his was soooo good, but mine looked good too. He did finally try a piece of my salmon appetizer and fish/clam entree, but passed on my dessert. With every bite he rolled his eyes and groaned. I've never enjoyed sharing my meal with a couple of strangers more
. He was really cute.
