YC water view CL or BWI deluxe CL for adults?

[2vets]

We are after an Epcot-area CL room, preferably in one of the "calmer" resorts in mid-Nov. Thoughts:
CL is obligatory to make DH happy
There will be no time spent in or around any pool
Freaky clown sightings aren't a problem
We're dog-lovers, so we are A-ok with pups at the resort
Pricing is close enough that it's not a factor

YC - newly refurbished rooms look gorgeous, love the coloration
Seems likely we'll have some view of Illuminations from our room (?), although DH likes walking outside to view them, so not critical
No noise from the Boardwalk

- Con - smaller room, new CL kind of an unknown (have seen varying reviews)

BWI -larger deluxe room
CL has an amazing reputation
CL here seems to get consistently fantastic reviews

- Con - older rooms - are they starting to look dated? Coloration/theming isn't my favorite, occasional reports of Boardwalk/boat noise (we're early risers, so this isn't a major deal unless it's ridiculous at midnight)

In short, I want a YC deluxe CL, but that ain't happening. What say you, Dis-ers? Thanks a million!

 

[gwynne]

I suggest you go with the BWI Deluxe CL room. You will have a water view, and a lot more space.
I really like YC and SAB, but in this case I think you get much more at BWI.

 

[CanadianAli]

I preferred BWI club level offerings over YC. However, the new rooms at YC would have me giving it a chance. The smaller size at BWI is always appealing to me on an adult trip.