Yahct Club Concierge or Polynesian Concierge?

[DisneyMomJen]

I am trying to talk DH into doing another tripd to Disney this December. We have stayed in the Polynesian Concierge previously and really enjoyed it. How does the Yacht Club Concierge compare to the Polynesian? Which would you choose between the two?

 

[YCFAN]

That is a topic that has been debated at length on these boards. It's really a matter of personal taste. I've stayed at both and prefer YC but many, many people prefer the Poly CL. It's much larger and the view is terrific. I like the decor at YC better and I like all the rooms for concierge being on the same floor. The CM's were friendlier IMHO at YC but you'll have other people say the opposite. I say just try each resort you're interested in and form your own opinion. The planning staff at YC/BC/BW can't be beat!