Just got back from our trip last night and we enjoyed a very good meal at YSH. As far as dress code, yes, they do let it slide and as with others, I was kind of bummed by that but to each their own I guess. I wore a dress with heels, hubby wore dress shorts and a nice button down, but for us it was a "date", to others it is simply dinner. Like I said to each their own.....
As far as food, we both had the porterhouse. If I have one complaint it was that they season the beef before cooking and I found my serving to be a bit to highly salted. I don't know for sure if it was a seasoned salt or regular salt mixed with other seasonings. It was not bad enough to send it back and when our waitressed asked our overall opinion of the meal at the end of our dinner, I mentioned it to her and she said that comment has been made before so I would advise asking that they not season the beef too heavily. The cuts of meat they use are fabulous so there is really no reason to do that! lol
The garlic rolls they serve as part of your bread course are insanely good too!
My biggest let down was the dessert selection. I think they could do better personally but I worked for a pastry chef for many years so I'm definitely biased.
Worth 2 credits? Yes but I think California Grill is still the best at WDW!