Woman claims she was groped by Donald Duck at Epcot, lawsuit says

Joined
May 27, 2006
Messages
39,677
http://www.orlandosentinel.com/the-...k-groping-case-epcot-20110103,0,5316435.story

The Associated Press
12:31 p.m. EST, January 3, 2011

PHILADELPHIA — A Pennsylvania woman who claims Donald Duck groped her at Disney's Epcot theme park can have her day in court, a federal judge has ruled.

Disney must defend April Magolon's claims that the character grabbed her breast as she held her child at the Walt Disney World park and then joked about it.

Magolon, 27, of Upper Darby, claims the May 2008 encounter left her with post-traumatic stress in the form of nightmares, digestive problems and other permanent injuries.

Her lawsuit also charges that Disney parks have a history of fondling complaints involving workers, and that that Disney has "condoned" their actions, putting profits over public safety.

In court papers, the defense argued that Magolon sued the wrong Disney corporate entity, and asked the judge to dismiss the suit or move it to Florida, where the encounter took place.

But U.S. District Judge John R. Padova refused, saying Magolon can proceed in Pennsylvania.

"She, her fiance (who was a witness to the alleged assault), and her treating doctors are all located in Pennsylvania," Padova wrote in a Dec. 29 ruling.

Disney also has greater resources to try the case in Pennsylvania than Magolon does to try it in Florida, he said.

Magolon does not have a listed number, and lawyers for her and for Disney did not immediately return calls for comment Monday on the ruling.

According to Magolon's suit, authorities in Florida received 24 related complaints in the week after a Walt Disney World employee dressed as " Tigger" was charged with molesting a 13-year-old girl and her mother in 2004. At least some were deemed credible and investigated by police, the suit said.

The man playing "Tigger" was later acquitted of criminal wrongdoing, after his lawyer donned the Tigger costume in court and argued that his client couldn't see much.

On the flip side, a 60-year-old Pennsylvania man was convicted last year of groping a woman in a Minnie Mouse costume at Walt Disney World.

John William Moyer, of Cressona, insisted he was innocent. But a Florida judge sentenced him to probation, community service and $1,000 court costs for misdemeanor battery.

The victim said she had to do everything possible to keep Moyer's hands off her breasts.
 
Will someone explain how a CM, dressed in a Donald Duck costume, could possibly be "groping" a guest while having those huge character hands in place?
 
post traumatic stress and digestive problems? I swear this is just shouting "false" to me. I mean those are serious side effects from something like that, especially since the incident happened in 2008....Just long enough that Disney might not have the records of who was in costume, where Donald was, or anything of that sort. Just a little sketchy to me, why wait this long?
 

While I don't believe this womans claim for one second Donalds hands are just a very basic glove and its not much different than the feeling of a regular thin glove.
 
I live not far from the town that this lady is from. That town had gone down hill really bad! Anything for a quick buck. I know not everyone from Upper Darby is a part of the "down hill", but my father who grew up there will be the first one to tell you that the place isn't very nice any more.

Not to mention. I work in Philadelphia, (which Upper Darby boarders) and the malpratice insurance that we have to pay (I work in a doctors office) is insane due to all of the frivolous (sp) law suits that people bring up in the city.
 
Those "injuries" are what you might expect for a soldier returning from combat in Afghanistan!!
This appears to be all about $$$$$$$----
 
While I don't believe this womans claim for one second Donalds hands are just a very basic glove and its not much different than the feeling of a regular thin glove.
If you look at the "Disney World Donald Duck" images on Google, it appears that they use a couple of different thicknesses of gloves for Donald, but from what I see there I wouldn't call any of them "thin" enough for any sort of tactile sensation. At worst, it'd be like trying to feel something through a medium weight pair of winter gloves.

On top of that, the woman really seems to be overplaying her hand with the whole PTSD thing!
 
If you look at the "Disney World Donald Duck" images on Google, it appears that they use a couple of different thicknesses of gloves for Donald, but from what I see there I wouldn't call any of them "thin" enough for any sort of tactile sensation. At worst, it'd be like trying to feel something through a medium weight pair of winter gloves.

On top of that, the woman really seems to be overplaying her hand with the whole PTSD thing!

I've actually slid one of them on before and you can feel decently well, they are certainly better than many of the other gloves/hands that are used.

This so called victim is a waste of space in society and has probably never done anything constructive in her life. Unfortunately this seems to be becoming the attitude of more and more people these days.
 
As common as these "groping" stories seem to be, can anyone direct me to where I can be groped by one of the princesses? pirate:
 
There should be repercussions for filing frivolous lawsuits, especially nowadays when people are suing everyone and anyone under the sun. I cannot possibly see how a person in a Donald Duck custome could grope anyone in such a manner where it would lead to PTSD. You would think that the CM assisting Donald Duck would have stopped Donald before the groping reached a level where it would cause the "victim" anything near PTSD.
 
There should be repercussions for filing frivolous lawsuits, especially nowadays when people are suing everyone and anyone under the sun. I cannot possibly see how a person in a Donald Duck custome could grope anyone in such a manner where it would lead to PTSD. You would think that the CM assisting Donald Duck would have stopped Donald before the groping reached a level where it would cause the "victim" anything near PTSD.

The problem is the law will never change because the people making the laws are in many cases Lawyers. You cant expect the bar association to do anything either since many of them have made their money from lawsuits etc.
 
There should be repercussions for filing frivolous lawsuits, especially nowadays when people are suing everyone and anyone under the sun.

I thought there were. Doesn't the losing party have to pay for their legal fees, plus the defending party's legal fees, etc? :confused3

I can see how doing something like that could trigger ptsd, but only if there was some pretty messed up underlying trauma already in play. However, in that case, wouldn't the guilty party be the one who caused the initial trauma?

I agree, this is a frivolous lawsuit. If someone in a humongous costume does something that seems inappropriate, I think you need to give them the benefit of the doubt. If anything say something like "excuse me! learn how to move in that thing!" and move on with your life. Having nightmares about giant donald ducks cackling over you or something is probably taking it too far. :rolleyes:
 
This is BS and I am sure there will be a settlement and who pays for this. WE do via higher ticket prices ect.


If this person is lying I hope Karma bites her in the butt.
 
I bet i can find 50 Lawyers that can explain how it could happen 35 diffrent ways.

Even if they could explain how it happened, it wouldn't make any sense, because I don't believe the CM could actually feel anything with that costume on. It could have been just an accidental contact :confused:
 
Are there really pt high schoolers playing princesses? I didn't know that.

High school age anyway -- I can't speak to whether or not they attend class or are enrolled. But yeah, they hire as young as 16 for princess/fairies at WDW.
 
There should be repercussions for filing frivolous lawsuits, especially nowadays when people are suing everyone and anyone under the sun. I cannot possibly see how a person in a Donald Duck custome could grope anyone in such a manner where it would lead to PTSD. You would think that the CM assisting Donald Duck would have stopped Donald before the groping reached a level where it would cause the "victim" anything near PTSD.

There would be less frivolous lawsuits if the plaintiff had to pay the attorney fees of the defendant if the plaintiff loses the lawsuit.
 


Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom