If you go to the Park and TSMM is down the entire day due to technical issues, does Disney owe you a refund? I think we would all agree, "No."
If one shop in Disneyland is closed for the day or one ride doesn't open does Disney owe a refund? What if the Tiki room doesn't open? That's a show.
Dreams, I was referring to your analogy above. It's a faulty analogy because with a park ticket, people have options of activities beyond those that are broken. With a WOC FP, there are no other options.
If all of the rides and attractions in DLR were broken and you bought a ticket, wouldn't you think you deserved a refund?
Dreams, we do see things differently. I appreciate your comments on so many threads on this board and respect your knowledge. I just think that Disney should have been more prepared for this and done more to ease a volitle situation.
If you are referring to the premium FPs, I think there is a value in the meal that has been eaten. There is a nominal difference in price between the meal and the WoC package. It is a free show. As for the time in line, if you camp out on Main Street for 2 hours (a CHOICE, not requirement) to see the fireworks and they are canceled, does Disney owe you something? I don't think so. I just don't view the world that way. Things happen. If Disney printed on the schedule that there is a fireworks show, allows people to camp out, and all the while does not plan on delivering said show, then something is owed to people for deception. If the fireworks "system" malfunctions, it's unfortunate, but something beyond Disney's control. Again, it's not the ONLY thing you can enjoy in the Park. With WoC package, many people have posted that they were told when making their PS that the show is not guaranteed.
I thought of the fireworks analogy. That is why I said this:
For those who either stood in line or got the picnic, Disney probably doesn't owe them another FP BUT good customer relations dictates that they should have AT LEAST tried to get them into the 11:15 show that night or a subsequent night.
I tried to say that they were not OWED anything, but the hype, publicity, and novelty of this show makes it more than a simple fireworks show. Currently it is a major draw to the parks, and that is why there were far more people upset and talking to guest relations than when a fireworks show is cancelled.
I think that Disney dropped the ball. They weren't prepared to even RESPOND to this issue, let alone find a reasonable solution.
Do I think every single person should have been given a new FP? No, but I given that people are reporting lots of room at the 11:15 shows and the fact that Disney CAN control the number of FP's handed out for future shows, they could have TRIED to accommodate people.
Again, it's a question of are you paying for the meal and receiving a preferred spot or are you paying for the spot and receiving the meal. I'm not saying I have the answer, I'm just presenting the question.
Here I strongly disagree with you.
Earlier you said:
I think Disney would argue, you are paying for the dinner and receiving priority seating for a FREE show that no one has pay any additional money (beyond Park admission) to see.
Of course people are paying for the preferred spot. They can eat anywhere, especially in places that are less expensive. If people simply wanted a good meal at Ariel's, wouldn't they go when they could get princess interaction too? No, they are going for the WOC preferred FP. Even the restaurants say it is a special menu. A WOC menu.
If an item (in this case, a WOC Preferred Viewing FP) can ONLY be obtained by paying money, it is not simply a free token thrown in. It is PART of what people paid for. They got their meal, now they want their show. It's a fair request, and it doesn't seem to be a hard request to fulfill.