We loved the SOG!
Have stayed at the Contemporary, Polynesian, Grand Floridian, and Boardwalk.
While we loved those places (a lot!) you can't beat the price at the SOG.
Room size is bigger than even the GF.
We really didn't feel that too much of the magic was missing. We could "purchase" more magic with the money we saved by doing other things we enjoy at Disney.
Don't think you'll regret staying at SOG.