Yes, all the reasons stated previously, in addition, for me, is that tropical feeling that just IS vacation. We've stayed at the Polynesian in Nov 02 and Dec 03 and in May 04 we walked over to see our home away from home for a stroll around the grounds. I got choked up wishing we'd chosen to stay there again. We'll be back again for two weeks in May 05. My DH has a hard time relaxing and isn't very "Disney", he loves the Polynesian too and always manages to relax and have a great time.
And the smell in the lobby, I don't know what it is, the banana leaves, the flowers, I don't know! But I do know, one day we were in Sam's Club and my five year old says "MOM! do you smell that? It smells JUST like the Polynesian!" and it DID! We both closed our eyes and stood there a minute.
The staff made us feel so welcomed, and my girls had a great time taking hula lessons (so did Mom!). In Dec we had a room in Tokelau, and if you turned your head to the right you could see Cinderella's castle from our balcony. Wishes were a little obstructed by the third floor balconies, but it was still visible!
I cried the first time we had to check out of the Polynesian, so my DH felt so bad for me he said "don't worry honey, we'll come back next year" My three year old says all the time "Momma, I miss the Pola Nesian!"
Oh I'm homesick now! Thanks to all the previous posters who let me take a little stroll down vacation memory lane!