Who would you bring back in the Wild Card on American Idol??

[SoonerKate]

Y'all, the thing about George is that he can sing. Not just pop or r&b or whatever -- I've heard him sing opera and it's absolutely chilling how amazingly talented he is. His voice is absolutely incredible -- opera, broadway, r&b, pop...you name it, he can nail it. Simon & Co. are really missing out on something incredible if they don't invite him back.

Yeah, he's the one they said looks too old! He already shaved his mustache; that was the main thing. He really doesn't look any older than 22 in person.

 

[suzannen]

I would also like to see George come back. His voice was far superior to quite a few that got through.

 

[coliebird]

Am I the only one that couldn't stand Scooter Girl? She just annoyed the heck out of me.

My vote - George - I thought he had a great voice and was unfairly cut b/c they thought he looked to "old".

 

[POLLY ANN]

Scootergirl was odd looking. Not that that should make a difference.\

Was George the black guy that wore the hat? If it is, I think he should come back, too!

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

Originally posted by coliebird
Am I the only one that couldn't stand Scooter Girl? She just annoyed the heck out of me.

My vote - George - I thought he had a great voice and was unfairly cut b/c they thought he looked to "old".

I don't think your the only on it;s just there were a lot of people who did like her

(fans) (you)

 

[poohbear2]

At first I REALLY couldn't stand Nicole. But as the show went on, she grew on me. I think she would be awesome in theater and movies. It would be really interesting to watch her on the wild card show and see how she has tried to change her image. I do feel sorry for her, however. One minute the judges say one thing and then later they say just the opposite. Tres confusing!!

I liked GEORGE TOO!! Nice voice and seemed like a real nice guy.

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

BUMP....................................

 

[Tina]

I don't remember his name (Michael C.... something... Cowan, maybe?), but he's the guy who sang Unchained Melody and blew Simon away. I thought he was fantastic AND had good looks.

Was I the only one who found Scooter Girl annoying?

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

George is cool I agree. He has a good voice and is cool. I think it is unfair he got voted out for his age, I just like Nicole better.




GO SCOOTER GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

Originally posted by Tina
I don't remember his name (Michael C.... something... Cowan, maybe?), but he's the guy who sang Unchained Melody and blew Simon away. I thought he was fantastic AND had good looks.

Was I the only one who found Scooter Girl annoying?

Like I said:


(fans) (you)

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

About that Michael C or Cowan he was a good singer but he was soooooooooooooooooo AROGANT. He was like " You heard my melody of Unchained Melody so don;t judge me on this performance" He got on my Nerves.



I also hate the 2 people that were in the pool! that guy was annoying!




The last person is that 16 year old. He isn't very good

 

[AspiringCindy]

I liked Scooter Girl! I think she has a unique personality and her voice sounded amazing in the trio! SO Broadway!

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

RIGHT ON!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[*Fantasia*]

Originally posted by coliebird
Am I the only one that couldn't stand Scooter Girl? She just annoyed the heck out of me.

My vote - George - I thought he had a great voice and was unfairly cut b/c they thought he looked to "old".

Yep, you're the only one so far. It's ok. It's your opinion.

I want my Scooter back!! Bring her back!! She is from my state!! She does look a little peculiar, but she can sing! She does need to find a style.

Scooter Girl Fan!!

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

Check out the new poll called wild card poll on the community board!



VOTE Nicole

 

[NoodlesTheRabbit]

Another fan of Scooter Girl!!

 

[MrsMud]

I was surprised to see Nicole (Scooter Girl), George (I'm young, I'm young!) and Michael "Mr Arrogant" Cowan get the boot. I wouldn't be surprised to see all three back for the Wildcard round. The first two I'd be happy to see again, but the last one should see if he can lose his attitude in time for next year's tryouts!

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

bump........................



GO NICOLE!!!!!

 

[MrsMud]

Just an FYI: Last night on American Idol, they specifically said that Wildcards could be brought back from any stage of the competition. I'm not sure if this is a departure from last year or not, but there you have it, straight from the horses mouth!
Which goes to my initial feeling that some of them were "let go" specifically to create fan interest, then they will be brought back for the Wildcard round. Phew... so there's still hope for Nicole and George afer all!

 

[1GoofyPittsburgher]

It would be hilarious if they brought back William Hung! SHE BANG! SHE BANG! oO SHE MOVES!


I have had no pro. training. O MY GOSH THATS THE SURPRISE OF THE CENTURY!!!!