Who will be voted off American Idol tonight?

[Muffy]

I think Elliot was GREAT last night! He really gave it his all. I think Katherine had a bad case of the nerves and may go home tonight.

 

[wdwgirl03]

I'm hoping it's Kat. I want the final two to be Chris and Elliott.

That would be great!!

All I know is that if it's Chris going tonight, my sister is going to be one unhappy camper...

 

[lucyblondecat]

Bye bye Kat.

 

[emmabelle]

Oops, forgot to say that I think it will be Kat going home. The posters here seem to get it right each week, so I hope tonight is no exception.

 

[Kim&Chris]

I'm hoping it's Kat. I want the final two to be Chris and Elliott.

I'll second that. Originally, I had no opinion about Elliott, but now I see his confidence level rising while still remaining humble. I like that alot - I hope he wins

 

[Minnie824]

Hopefully Katherine...if not then Elliott..I don't think either of them are good, and neither should be this far in the competition. But Katherine forgot her words!! You can't be in the top 3 and forget words.

 

[minnieandmickeymouse]

I think it could be elliott.

 

[DISUNC]

Bye BYE Katarine!!!!!! She 'phoned' it in last night!

But I now have a new respect for Elliot! I haven't seen a performance on that show with such a intensity since Fantasia sang "Summer Time"!

Me got goosebumps!!!!!!!
The other 2 guys were good last night...but just that "good"!

 

[Virgo10]

I think it may be Chris because Kat is someone the guys like looking at. However.......... it should be Kat that goes. She just doesn't seem to "get" the songs. Even Kellie, as ditzy as she was, seemed to grasp what she was singing.

 

[Brutie]

I hope that the girl goes home. I have not liked her from the beginning. I havent watched in about a month or so until last night, just havent been able to get into it this year for some reason.

I do not like the elliott guy either, something strange about him. He has an odd shaped head, face or something but the 2 dont go together right or something, I know its just me, but something about him is just kinda creepy. Maybe he just has a horse face, I dont know...lol

I hope the final 2 will be Taylor and Chris. If either one of them wins I'll be happy. I think they might both end up with some type of record deal. Taylor is so much fun and Chris is just sexy without really trying to be.

 

[BuzzBoyMom]

I hope that the girl goes home. I have not liked her from the beginning. I havent watched in about a month or so until last night, just havent been able to get into it this year for some reason.

I do not like the elliott guy either, something strange about him. He has an odd shaped head, face or something but the 2 dont go together right or something, I know its just me, but something about him is just kinda creepy. Maybe he just has a horse face, I dont know...lol

I hope the final 2 will be Taylor and Chris. If either one of them wins I'll be happy. I think they might both end up with some type of record deal. Taylor is so much fun and Chris is just sexy without really trying to be.

Did anyone else ever read that blog about how when Paula teared up over Chris' performance (several weeks ago) that she was tearing up b/c she felt he was so good but knew that he wasn't going to make it....like the program was fixed? I've heard that one several times.

 

[Nancyg56]

I think that it will be Kat. I really do not like her, but thought that she has been okay thus far. Last night she was terrible.

 

[Katerbug]

I sure hope Katherine goes home tonight!!!!!!!!

 

[PixiePop]

I think Katherine should go home tonight. Forgetting the lines at this stage in the game.....not good.

 

[mouseRD]

Oops, she was voted off (mistake in IMHO!); what a talent! However, I, along with my family & friends in SC, NJ, & AZ am rooting for Elliot! Elliot! Elliot! What an incredible voice! I guess I wouldn't be surprised or disappointed if someone else won, though, because all are talented. Katherine's performance was not up to par last night & based on that she should be going home, but she has popularity on her side & a huge fan base. I think it's up for grabs!

 

[irishbosoxfan]

It should be Kat who goes home---DialIdol had E at #1 for votes last night!!
After this I hope it is Taylor who leaves us---We are voting for a singer and his seizures are extremely distracting!--I feel like he should suddenly sprout a tail while on stage and bounce around on it like Tigger!!!

 

[dturner]

Before they sang last night I figured Elliott would be next to go home but after he performed I agree with SImon, he deserves to go on to the next round.

Katherine should go home or there will be a SHOCKER ELIMINATION and Chris goes home which will make me so mad and sad .

 

[CookieGVB]

I actually missed the show last night - anyone have links to the site that has the mp3s?

 

[MerryPoppins]

I like all four. At this point I sort of feel like I know them all and I hate for any of them to go home.

If I had to choose, I guess I would send home Kat. But before last night I would have said Elliot. They are both in third place in my book at this point in the game. Such a shame that Kat got nervous and forgot her words. I think that might have sealed her fate. You can't do that this late in the competition.

 

[Robinrs]

I like all four also, at different levels, though. This is the first time I've ever felt this way down to the wire on AI, I usually HATED someone!

I think it will be Kat, she really messed up last night. At this stage in the game there is no room for that. Chris, on the other hand, has lost a bit of his edge. Elliott was awesome last night. Taylor will always be my sentimental favorite.

We'll see. This is the first time in awhile when the "loser" wasn't a sure thing.