If it's free or an upgrade from free, sounds like a good deal. We paid for the dining plan a couple of years ago and I hated it. I'm one of those people who was more worried about maximizing the value of the plan (am I getting my money's worth or, better still, coming out ahead?!) that I didnt' really enjoy the dining experience. Since I had to pay taxes and tip anyway, it didn't offer "paid in advance" convenience either. I'd rather just pay as I go. now if was for free... then that's a different story! My three kids are now "adults" under the plan and couldn't eat all that was offered on a regular dining plan. I can't imagine throwing in appetizers, too!