That moment is the precise reason that everyone should try 1900 PF for dinner in their lifetime. The Tremaines are so freaking funny, I am laughing just thinking about them. Lady T is just so no-nonsense and says the funniest one liners but keeps her straight face, and Anastasia & Drizella are so over the top with their cattiness toward Cinderella and their flirtation with the boys/men in the room. I LOVE 1900 PF and I would eat there again and again.
The one thing that I noticed this year that has changed is the dessert - last year we were served a big sundae to share and it was really great, this year we had just the standard buffet desserts (and btw I totally agree w/ you on the chocolate crusted key lime pie..ick).
I say, also - yes to detailed dining reports! I love the extra detail, I find it really helpful to read others' thoughts on the different TS restaurants (especially since we have similarly aged daughters). It gives me ideas for next time!
Aren't they great?!? Even Maddie thought it was funny.
The desserts are just not good. However, I think that the only buffet with good desserts is Cape May. I am an Oreo BonBon obsessive.

I love key lime pie,and that was just bad--in Florida.
Thanks for the feedback! I'll definitely keep doing them.

Maddie is calling her "Brave" too! She keeps asking "What's her name again Mommy?"
GRRRRR. I would love to go on a trip that's been completely planned for me (well, not really, I'm too much of a control freak-but you know what I mean), and my MiL acted like a toddler. Yet, she's more than happy to go along with them with nothing planned? Nothing planned for my 3 year old niece.

The woman has been going to Disney for almost 30 years!!! She knows better!
My fave person in DH's family advised me to say I'm too busy to help. They are most likely not going to have a good trip even if I step in (no time! they want to go in June! wouldn't you have at least made a hotel reservation? even if you were going somewhere less popular? they're nuts!). She's exactly right, and my SiL is a lot like my MiL so guess who would get blamed if when they have a terrible time despite my best efforts. She's so right, I just can't help them.
Great update. I can't believe the tip your MIL gave you toward the dinner? Trust me, I won't be taking any MIL's on my trips.
We've never done 1900 Park Fare. My best friend and adopted sis here from the DIS, has kept me away from there as she hated it when she went (and she is often referred to as the Queen of Food Porn on the DIS. But you make it sound like it's not too bad.

Can't wait to hear if you finally get on some rides.
Thanks! That tip still confuses me. Even though we used
DDP, the price is still on the bill. Not sure what message she was hoping to send. It sure didn't say "Thanks for letting me enjoy WDW with my oldest grandchild"
You know, we really, really hated the food at Park Fare last trip. DH described it as "sucky"

The only reason we gave it another try is the Tremaines. They are
that entertaining. Plus, we were trying to do one character meal each day, and 1900 worked out for this day.
The food was much better than last time, but still not WOW. It was better than most buffet food though. It really is way more about the entertainment there, and for us that's good enough (for one meal at least!)