Who ever organized my kids Kindergarten field day needs a lesson

Disney1fan2002

<font color=red>Like OMG the TF is SOO psyched to
Joined
Jun 21, 2002
Messages
12,072
on how to NOT be an idiot!

I just got back from DS6 field day. OMG! WHO'S brilliant idea was it to give the top 3 finishers only in each event a ribbon sticker?

By the 3rd event, 4 kids were crying uncontrollably. WHY? I think you can guess. DS didn't cry, but to see his face drop when he realized he wasn't one of the kids getting a ribbon. :sad2:

I mean, I am not one of those people that think kids need to go through their entire childhood without ever knowing what it feels like to lose. I think that aspect of our society is getting ridiculous, but COME ON! They are 5 and 6 years old!


Yeah, brilliant, I tell ya! NOT. geesh
 
I couldn't go to our field day, but I pick DD up and she asks if she can have a popsicle when we get home. She says that she didn't finish enough events to get get one at school. (She picked her best friend who goes in the am class and he's got some attention/anger issues so he held her back.) Anyway she was the only one in her K class that didn't get a popsicle. It's sugar water for goodness sake let all the kids have one!

I understand your frustration!
 
Nicolepa said:
I couldn't go to our field day, but I pick DD up and she asks if she can have a popsicle when we get home. She says that she didn't finish enough events to get get one at school. (She picked her best friend who goes in the am class and he's got some attention/anger issues so he held her back.) Anyway she was the only one in her K class that didn't get a popsicle. It's sugar water for goodness sake let all the kids have one!

I understand your frustration!

No no no no NO! You have got to be kidding me! An adult actually refused your DD a popsicle because she did not finish the required number of events????? HOLY FREAKIN CRAP
 
musclecar_72 said:
I don't see what the big deal is! When I was in kindergarden only the winner got a ribbon!

The big deal is, field day is supposed to be FUN. But, when you have kids crying, because they are not good enough to get a ribbon, because they "lost", it becomes not fun. They are 5 and 6 years old. Still too young, IMO to be told "get over it".
 
At our elem school field day they don't do ribbons. They do the activities and leave it at that. They all have a great time! They have some winning/losing activites, ie tug-a-war, a ball game, etc, but they those were group activities. This was for K and 1st grade. The older kids are broken down into 2nd and 3rd grade and 4th and 5th, but they are on different days, with different activities. In past years the kids got popsicles (all the kids got them), but I don't think the kids got them this year.
 
OK--the popsicle thing is really pretty horrifying. That I can clearly see a problem with!

I don't really have a beef with only awarding prizes to the winners. As long as a huge deal isn't made over it, 5 and 6 year olds should be expected to understand that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose, and it doesn't matter that much because the whole point was to have a fun time while playing the game.
 
pearlieq said:
OK--the popsicle thing is really pretty horrifying. That I can clearly see a problem with!

I don't really have a beef with only awarding prizes to the winners. As long as a huge deal isn't made over it, 5 and 6 year olds should be expected to understand that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose, and it doesn't matter that much because the whole point was to have a fun time while playing the game.

I agree, the kids that win should get the ribbons.

Maybe next year the parents can get together and make up little treat bags to give all the kids at the end of the day. That way all kids will go home with something.
 
I think the winners should get the ribbons, and everyone should get a popsicle.

I helped with "fun" day at my niece's school the other day. We had a water balloon toss, which made the ground kind of muddy. The last group of kids ended up pretty dirty. I'm sure parents were complaining about our poor planning that night.
 
I see nothing wrong with the top 3 kids getting the winning ribbons - they won!

Now at our field day everyone gets a participation ribbon before the day starts and then we have standard ribbons, but you must meet the standard to get the ribbon - alot of kids don't.

We have had this arguement at our school before but getting a 1st, 2nd or 3rs place ribbon and no one else getting anything is the same as speeches or County Fair entries. Only a certain amount of kids are picked to go on with their speeches and only a certain amount of paintings and poems are picked to go to the fair.

When have become a society thta thinks everything has to be fair and that is just not reality. Some kids are better at sports and athletics while other kids are musically inclined - let the kids excel at what they are good and let them be rewarded for it.
 
My dd is in pre-k. At her field day everybody got a gold medal and a popsical stick. Plus it was pouring raining that day instead of cancelling it that held it inside and Dora came. :wave:
 
Field Day is supposed to encourage kids to find exercise and sports enjoyable. Those that are naturally good at sports will get a ribbon for winning and that positive feedback will encourage them to keep doing sports. Those that need the most encouragement to be active (the ones that are not naturally athletic) get reinforced AGAIN that it is not fun when they don't get a ribbon.

Do away with the ribbons altogether. It doesn't need to be competitive, just fun. If you do have ribbons there should be one for everyone and a quick thinking and funny adult should be the one handing them out. There can be one for "most creative runner" "most colorful runner" "best slow motion runner" "fanciest shoes runner". You get the idea. And EVERYONE should get a freaking popsicle!

At the elementary school level there does not need to be this kind of competition. This is when good habits and enjoyment need to be reinforced.
 
I don't really see why EVERYONE should get a ribbon; just the top winners should, or ribbons shouldn't be handed out at all, period. At 5 & 6 they should begin realizing that sometimes you win and sometimes you don't. They will have to learn at some point anyway...even if you waited until they were 15 years old before allowing them to lose, I'm sure they probably still have a fit even at that age.

I like a previous poster's suggestion of the winners getting a ribbon, and every participant gets a popsicle.
 
I think the purpose of field day is to show the importance of physical activity, give the teachers a day off from lesson planning at the end of the year, give the children a physical outlet for the antsyness they are going through so close to the end of the school year and give the parents a chance to observe (if it's something the parents are invited to). I don't think that ribbons add to that.

I'm not opposed to ribbons at other events and I think that the group activities that our school had were great. Like I said, some had winners and losers (and I know that my son doesn't like to be a loser, but he has to deal with that), but it was in a group cooperative setting. The ribbons wouldn't have added anything.

IF a school was going to do ribbons, I think participation ribbons for all and then 1st, 2nd and 3rd place ribbons for the others would be fair, but make sure that the events are all judged fairly, too. Ends up taking a fun day and making the adults have to really police it. There wasn't any of that at our field day and most of it ran smoothly with the 5th graders in charge.
 
As someone that always gets stuck organizing these things (I always get suckered in when no one else steps forward) I can assure you that these things aren't done to be mean or to exclude kids. Sorry, but this hits a sore spot with me - There's nothing like giving up your personal time and working like crazy setting these things up only to get criticized for everything. If you disagree with the way things are done, maybe get involved in the planning meetings or become part of the PTO and work on next year's field day.
 
It's like Syndrome in The Incredibles said "When everybody's super, nobody will be." If you don't acknowledge those that achieved more by distinguishing them from the rest of the crowd, then everyone is average and no one is above-average. If you're going to give equal reward to every one, then you shouldn't keep score or points and no one should be eliminated from the event. If the kids realize that they are going to get the same reward as everyone else, they won't try as hard.

If you want to acknowledge everyone to some extent, then give everyone a participation ribbon. Then give the place finishers special ribbons in addition to the participation ribbon.
 
Lets do it this way. Let all the kids run a 20 yd dash. Time them and then have a staggered start and move the faster kids back. Then they all can finish at exactly the same time. Gather in a circle group hug and sing kumbaya! :bitelip:
 
pearlieq said:
OK--the popsicle thing is really pretty horrifying. That I can clearly see a problem with!

I don't really have a beef with only awarding prizes to the winners. As long as a huge deal isn't made over it, 5 and 6 year olds should be expected to understand that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose, and it doesn't matter that much because the whole point was to have a fun time while playing the game.

These were my thoughts as well.

Someone needs to speak to the person who refused a popsicle to 1 child. IMO, that's totally uncalled for. I hope you bought her a whole box of them when she got home, Nicolepa. Your poor little one. :guilty:
 
My DS5 just had his field day last month and there were no ribbons or any competitions - the different events were things like ring tosses and bounce houses. He actually said he was disappointed because somehow he got it into his head that there would be races and he wanted to see who the fastest boy in Kindergarten was (and he knew it wasn't him! :rotfl: ). Now waaaaaaaayyyy back in the day when I did field day we did have ribbons for most of the activities, but the thing I liked about it was not all activities were athletic. For example, there was a contest for the biggest bubble you could blow. There was a sit down one where you would get a long word and come up with as many words as you could from it (a way to get us inside and cool off), a game of Simon Says which is more brain powered than physical, etc. There were also other activities that had no ribbons like skating/roller blading in one of the emptied parking lots, etc...why do I remember this? Well, it was done the exact same way K-5th with no variation so it was forever etched in my brain!! :goodvibes But I liked the way it was done and I felt like it was a good compromise. (And yes, we all got popsicles!)
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom