I think Toad Hall is our fave, the fish is awfully nice - the portions decent and it even comes in a basket with special newspaper wrapping (or was doing that when we last went)
Colonel Hathi's is maybe my least fave, I had the salmon topped pizza - which while nice enough at the time...I chucked it up once we got back to the hotel ;_; Not really their fault though, it was during the "all meals" free promo and I think I just couldn't handle all the food intake we had (part of the reason we're not doing half board this time)