Which would you cancel? Cape May Buffet or Boma?

[Cmbar]

We have reservations for two different restaurants and have to cancel one! Which one would you cancel?

Cape May Buffet Dinner or
Boma at AKL for Dinner

Also have to choose between,
Crystal Palace Dinner OR
1900 Park Fare Dinner

Thanks!!

 

[inloveindisney]

Not been to the others for dinner, but I'd cancel Boma on the first two choices. We didn't care for Boma, although others tend to rave about it.
Cape may, however, was fabulous and it was quite busy when we were there, so others must like it too!
I found a lot more on the cape may buffet than I found at Boma. Everything at Cape may was fantastic

 

[MPLsDad]

If you like shrimp, mussells, and clams, CANCEL BOMA. If you like variety and yummy cooked food that you won't get anywhere else, CANCEL CMB.

I would never return to Crystal Palace for dinner even though I've never had dinner at 1900 Park Fare (but have an ADR come April).

 

[juju]

I thought Cape May was icky. I love seafood, but thought theirs was overcooked and didn't seem very fresh. Boma at least had some different dishes than the usual WDW buffet fare.

 

[bigbabyblues]

I'd cancel Cape May if I had to choose, and definitely 1900 PF. We didn't care for it at all, and won't be giving it another try.

 

[KingdomHearts]

We have reservations for two different restaurants and have to cancel one! Which one would you cancel?

Cape May Buffet Dinner or
Boma at AKL for Dinner

Also have to choose between,
Crystal Palace Dinner OR
1900 Park Fare Dinner

Thanks!!

I would cancel Boma but between Crystal or 1900 that is a really hard choice. Either one is really good! Good luck!

 

[JenSop]

Next to Le Cellier, Boma is our absolute favorite WDW restaurant. I have not been to Cape May Cafe yet, but LOVE, LOVE Boma. Such a great variety of new things to try.

We will be doing both on our next trip.

 

[audisight]

Between Boma's and Cape May I would do Cape May. Everything at Cape may was so yummy. For me Boma's was just ok.
Between Crystal Palace and 1900 I would pick Crystal Palace. The food is good at both places, I just like eating at MK more then the Grand.

 

[becka]

We didn't like Cape May but did like Boma so I would keep Boma.

We enjoyed 1900 Park Fare but I know CP gets great reviews so if you are already in the MK go with CP but if you are out of the park then go with 1900 PF.

 

[CEDmom]

I'd cancel Cape May in a second over Boma. The food at Cape May is nothing special. I've had much better at Red Lobster. I'd keep 1900. The food is quite good. Not as good as Boma but much better than Cape May.

 

[wdwthanksgiving]

i would cancel cape may ---we had the longest wait (45 min past our adr), the food was average...boma has interesting food mixed with food that is good and "safe" for most palates and the hotel is beautiful and fun to explore after dinner.

 

[Stacerita]

I would cancel Cape May and keep Boma.

 

[Twende]

I always enjoy Boma. I think it is great. Breakfast is wonderful there too! Try the Frunch!

We did Cape May on on last trip and we also enjoyed it. It was good.



We have never eaten at Crystal Palace but I can tell you I will not return to 1900 Park Fare. It was poor. We waited forever to get in and then the gave us a hard time about one in our party who can not transfer to a chair. Our server was slow! The food was skimpy, over cooked, and even the carving station meat was very fatty. The lines to get food were long. The character interaction was okay but not out of this world fun.

So my advice would be to do Boma and Cape May and skip the other two!

 

[quixoticvalue]

I'd KEEP Boma--great variety and everything was cooked wonderfully. I liked both 1900 park and Crystal palace so thats a toughie.... ehhh keep crystal palace!

 

[IWISHFORDISNEY]

I have been to all 4 and my vote is:

Keep Boma and CP we do these every trip.

Drop Cape May and 1900 I wont go back to either of these.

 

[tickledtink33]

I personally prefer Boma. Everytime I stay at the Beach club and walk by the Cape May Cafe at dinner time, the very very fishy smell makes me gag. However, if you have any picky eaters in your group, they may have a hard time finding foods they will like on the Boma buffet.

 

[WildGrits]

However, if you have any picky eaters in your group, they may have a hard time finding foods they will like on the Boma buffet.

I was just going to say that.

My whole group, minus my husband loved Boma. The soups are incrediable. Most of our group are "veggie-tarians". This was one of the best places to take them.

My husband on the other hand likes what he likes the way he likes it. And that is it. He is not so much picky, he'll try anything once or twice, as much as set in this way as to how he likes things cooked. He doesn't like Boma. And he isn't going to make a meal out of what is on the Kids pod.

The Cape May Cafe is a Clam Bake. Not exactly what we consider Seafood. It is a traditional Clam Bake. If you like clam bakes then you will love them. We don't care for them. We like seafood such as Mahi-Mahi, Tuna, fried Smelts or Spots. That is not what this place is.

Before our recent trip in 9/07, the last time we had eaten at the Crystal Palace, it was a Cafeteria. Yep, that's a long time. We went again. OMG!!! It was very good. In the top three of our fav places now.

I have never eaten at 1900 so I can't comment.

 

[Ron from Michigan]

I would cancel CMB.

 

[maraki527]

I would cancel boma we always enjoy Cape May Clambake

 

[antmaril]

We ate at both Cape May and Boma in late August (this was our first visit to Cape May, and our fourth visit to Boma). We enjoyed Cape May, but Boma would be my first choice. More interesting foods and a more unique experience overall.