I'm no help to you.....because we're not a 'gaming' family. BUT
I went to game stop, and looked at the different games available for the playstations, xbox, and game cube. To be honest, my 9 and 10 DD's would be perfectly happy with all the game cube games. So thats what I went with for DD9. For christmas, I've also bought her, Finding Nemo, Shrek 2, a Mario game (blanking on the real title), ATV racing, and Need For Speed 2. We played the Shrek game when we bought the system, because we bought the used one for 59.99 I also added the 1-year replacement for 9.99. I had to make sure it worked lol...
Maybe, if we were into game systems, we'd have gone with an X-Box type, but really this will suit our family fine. And, the games seem to be cheaper than the other systems, even full priced at
walmart etc.. they are cheaper than the ps2 or xbox 360 games.
I think for us, we made the right decision....good luck because this could be expensive!
Brandy