I have stayed at CBR twice. Before my first visit, I was a little concerned about whether or not I would like it and feel comfortable. Outside of Disney World, I had never stayed at a 'motel' or a hotel that didn't have inside corridors, or room service, and a few other amenities. Call me spoiled, I don't care, I just had never stayed at a place like that. I tried CBR, and it was great! I felt safe, and returned for a second trip as a single mom with DS.
While I would definitely prefer to stay deluxe, as a single mom, I simply can't afford $300 - 400 a night right now for a week. After much research and reading here on the DIS, I am considering a trip to POP in January for DS and myself. I have read many times on here where people actually prefer POP over some of the deluxe resorts. I don't think we can compare WDW resorts, value, moderate or deluxe to a typical resort or hotel outside of the WDW. I think that there are definitely going to be differences for us staying at POP, but we are at Disney. POP looks so 'fun and crazy' and our trip in January will be for a long weekend if we go, and so we won't be in the room much at all. I think that makes a difference. Both of our trips to CBR were longer and we actually spent time at the resort. Little kids screaming drive me crazy, so I don't know if I would want to spend a week there, but we are going to give this a try. If we don't get the value price, we would probably not be going for another 6 months or year.
I think that value, moderate, and deluxe give us a good description on the type of experience it will offer us. I have read several times and I agree that the resort you choose should reflect the experience you are looking for for that particular trip. Before, I wanted a 'vacation' experience, therefore CBR worked for us. This purpose of this trip is going to be for the park experience, and to have 'fun', and I think POP will meet that need.