I was afraid EVERYONE would say AoA when I asked. Good to see different answers. I'm asking for myself, wife, DS-12 and DD-15. We've stayed offsite, POFQ and WL (honeymoon, no kids). We've felt both onsite felt "disney-like" in their own way. You know, Disney service, hidden Mickeys, well thought out imagineering (the tour at WL showcased the details. Amazing!). We are currently booked for a coupla days at Pop then 4 days at CSR. My wife and I think CSR looks beautiful and Pop just looks like a cheap hotel with cool theming. I'm just afraid Pop will be too cheezy and "kiddie" for us adults and CSR may not feel Disney enough for everyone. My wife didn't like DHS because it didn't feel like she was in Disney (I get it. Not as magical now that I have kids. I like it but not near as much as when I was a teen). We had a POR Royal Room booked but I can save money by booking standard at CSR, we probably won't be in the room enough to appreciate the RR and we've already been to POFQ and used POR pool and such. It was nice but we all wanna try something new. I'm just overthinking everything right now hoping all goes well.