Which Personal Navigator is More Accurate?

[grammie12]

We are currently booked on the Sept 5, 2015 Fantasy Western C cruise and are planning our activities.

There are two sets of 2014 Personal Navigators I've seen online; one from Sept 13; and the other from Sept 27. The Sept 27 one differs in the times of the Halloween celebrations from the previous one.

Which one do you think would be more accurate to go by? And do you think our sailing will actually be a Halloween sailing? (Last year Sept 6 was the first Halloween sailing on the Fantasy - it was the Eastern).

Thanks for your help!!

 

[PrincessShmoo]

We are currently booked on the Sept 5, 2015 Fantasy Western C cruise and are planning our activities.

There are two sets of 2014 Personal Navigators I've seen online; one from Sept 13; and the other from Sept 27. The Sept 27 one differs in the times of the Halloween celebrations from the previous one.

Which one do you think would be more accurate to go by? And do you think our sailing will actually be a Halloween sailing? (Last year Sept 6 was the first Halloween sailing on the Fantasy - it was the Eastern).

Thanks for your help!!

Actual times as well as activities can vary from cruise to cruise. It would be hard to say one was more accurate than the other.

I'd think you may have a fair to good chance that a Sep 5 cruise would be one of the Halloween ones.

We were on the Sept 27 cruise last year

 

[grammie12]

Actual times as well as activities can vary from cruise to cruise. It would be hard to say one was more accurate than the other.

I'd think you may have a fair to good chance that a Sep 5 cruise would be one of the Halloween ones.

We were on the Sept 27 cruise last year

Oh, I guess I was under the impression that the Navigators were the same (as far as activity times, etc) for any particular itinerary!

Wow! I seriously think I've learned SO much from this board, and yet realize there's still SO much I don't know!

Thank you so much for that, PrincessSchmoo...I can alway count on you to have the right info!

We can't wait for our cruise! Sounds so fun!

 

[Melissa S]

They are similar but not the same. You can get a good general idea. I love to over plan but this is the one area where you can enjoy some surprises

 

[suebecdan]

Were you able to find a navigator for Fantasy Western cruise? My gf is booked for JUne 13 and would love to see one.

 

[Maggie'sMom]

Were you able to find a navigator for Fantasy Western cruise? My gf is booked for JUne 13 and would love to see one.

You can find old Personal Navigators at http://disneycruiselineblog.com/personal-navigators/.

 

[ColoradoDisneyFreaks]

The answer is, they both are. While a lot of the activities repeat from cruise to cruise, the times may differ, and they are always rolling off activities that don't have high participation rates and tossing new ones in there to see what people enjoy. This isn't something you can plan like a park visit, you really just have to go day by day. You can plan excursions, but activities for sea days and evenings you can really only plan the night before when you get the Navigator.