Which one for birthday dinner??

[MissMet]

I'm trying to figure out which of these restaurants is the best for my friend's birthday dinner. It is his first time to WDW & he will be turning 26.

I had planned to have his birthday dinner at '50s Prime Time, but now we are going to the P&PP on the day of his birthday & our ADR was at 6:15. So now I need to rearrange my ADRS. Which out of the above, would be the best option?? He will really get into whatever is done to him, so I really want one that will be memorable.

Thanks!

 

[Eeyore's Pal]

I think your original choice is the best -- 50s Prime Time.
If you let them know it's his birthday, it's the kind of place where the CMs will make sure his meal is memorable.