Which of these two wheeled duffels should I buy?

[frannn]

Flying on Jetblue in August and DH needs a new checked bag. We prefer wheeled duffels. Jetblue limit is 62" total, 50 lbs. I found two duffels on Ebags and need help choosing:
1) 1500D Polyester, Olympia brand, 57" total, 7 lbs, $33.50
2) Nylon (not sure what kind), Ful brand, 60", 10 lbs, telescoping handle $56
Both have drop bottom sections and in-line skate wheels. I have an older Ful bag from Costco and love it, but they don't sell them anymore. I think the Ful is probably better for the 3 extra inches, but I was hoping to get some input from my DIS buddies!

 

[tweety38]

Have you looked at LL Bean. They warranty theirs forever. Great quality.

 

[wishuponastar42]

Get whichever one has four wheels...if it doesn't have four wheels it is guaranteed to be thrown and/or slid on the ground because they can't roll it.

 

[BCV2003]

I would vote for the Ful one just from my experience. We have two Ful brand ones from Costco, one new one and one older one and they are both of equal quality.

I did purchase an LL Bean one for my niece who went to Ireland last year and I didn't like it at all. The material was too soft and it was one giant compartment (unlike the Ful ones) and it was just too floppy, not made as well as the Ful ones.

 

[Pooh2]

We got the Bean's carryall duffel.
It was 48 lbs when we had it loaded up.

http://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/6393...R0&page=carryall-rolling-gear-bag-extra-large