Which of these three DTD Restaurants is the best?

[maraki527]

I have been to all three and Portebello Yacht Club is the best. It is the only one that we continued to go to. The other two once was enough .

 

[Jrabbit910]

DH and I want to try something new at DTD in January, and we've never been to Cap'n Jack's, Fulton's Crab House or Portobello Yacht Club. Which is the best? We're going back to Bongo's, which we loved, and finally trying Wolfgang Puck Cafe, too.

Thanks!

My DH & I were so disappointed in Fultons Crab house... If I had to pick between the choices you gave then it would have to be the PYC... If you do however want to try out of the box; go w/ House of BLUES... its really good... (i also think Wolfgangs & bongos are great)

 

[Camster0307]

We've been to both Fulton's & Portabello - liked them both; but always choose Fulton's year after year for our DTD meal. Many have mentioned how expensive it is (and it is!), but I've ordered 1/2 portions of some dinners for obviously half the price - good deal ! Especially the KingCrab legs!

 

[Tricia1972]

I love Fulton's!

 

[MissMet]

This is my thing with Fultons. If you're not willing to pay A LOT than you will not like it.

The first time we went was for lunch. It was when they had the Silver Plan- 2TS meals a day. It took 2 TS for dinner but only 1 TS for lunch. So we went for lunch & thought it was mediocre. We didn't understand why it took 2 TS for dinner it was so forgetable. So after eating we were on our way out & decided to check out the dinner menu to figure out what was up. When we saw the menu we were VERY intrigued! So we went back & used our 2 TS! After we were done, the check was over $300 for the four of us! Thank God for the Silver Plan. It was the best meal I've ever eaten at WDW!!! Anyone who says it's not good, didn't order correctly at the SEAFOOD place. I got the claws & they come already cracked in half! Just a plate full of precracked claws. All you have to do is pick them up with the fork & dip them in the butter! No getting messy. So gooood!

Moral of the long story... you will only find Flutons amazing if you go for dinner & are not worried about the price of the meal. My entree was $45 alone- but worth every penny!

 

[Tinkerbell1013]

SOO glad you nixed Cap'n Jacks from your choices. It was truly awful when I was there May 2007. I will NEVER be back to Cap'n Jacks. A complete waste of time and of a credit on the DDP.

I've never been to either Portabello or Fulton's but I realllllly want to give Fulton's a try.